4 ms·
I'm not sure I'd want to work for someone who didn't understand the difference between computer science and programming. It really is like the difference betwe
by kenjackson 16y ago
I'm not sure I'd want to work for someone who didn't understand the difference between computer science and programming.
It really is like the difference between a degree in physics and being a car mechanic. You can be a great car mechanic without a degree in physics, but the intent of the physics degree isn't to create great car mechanics.
I was probably a better C programmer at age 15 than most professional programmers I've run across in my career. With that said I didn't know about the Halting problem nor the Chomsky Hierarchy nor even things like amortized cost nor really any asymptotic complexity analysis. Do any of those things help me at my day job... maybe a little, but not much. Certainly I'd be better served reading the .NET Fx docs or Java docs or some JQuery books. But that's not why I got a degree in CS.
- brianlash 16y agoAs a non-programmer I really like your comment but you leave me wanting more. I understand that programming and computer science are different animals, but I guess in terms of your example I don't understand why someone pursuing a profession in programming would want or need the CS background? Are you getting at the pursuit of higher understanding angle i.e. separating the pragmatic pursuit of workplace advancement from the more selfless or idealistic pursuit of knowledge?
- kenjackson 16y agoI'm not sure I'd say it is more selfless or idealistic, but I do think that college, at least as I see it, serves a very unique purpose. It's goal is to take great ideas over time and teach those ideas to new students of the field. And computer science as a field is more about the science of computing, than it is about programming. Generally programming is taught as a way to understand different manifestations of computing. To answer your first question, pursuing a profession in programming doesn't require a CS degree. And it's probably only marginally beneficial to improving the quality of your work in _most_ programming jobs. I do think we can view programming as more of a vocational skill. There will be some jobs that require CS backgrounds, but for the most part it's a lot closer to writing in that there is a suitable job for almost every level of skill.
- BahUnfair 16y agoI would say that learning for the sake of learning is a far more selfish choice than moving into the work force and being a productive member of society. But that isn't going to stop me from choosing learning and maybe putting it into use in the far less selfish application of research. (I do biotechnology)
- thunk 16y ago> I'm not sure I'd want to work for someone who didn't understand the difference between computer science and programming. It's not a misunderstanding. You just can't get a degree in programming. 90% [1] of students in CS departments are there to be industry coders. [1] True bogus fact.
- pwim 16y agoIn Canada at least, you can get a degree in Software Engineering which is aims to teach you the skills you'll need to develop software (not just programming though).
- ovi256 16y agoIn most European countries too. You can get a Computer Engineering degree, equivalent to an US MSc in Engineering, with a Software, Hardware, Networking or some other topic focus. Mine was Telecommunications :) These degrees are a mix of various proportions of traditional Computer Science, Electrical Engineering and software craft, depending upon your focus.
- jrockway 16y agoComputer Engineering and Software Engineering are two completely different things. SE is "testing, version control, design patterns", but CE is electrical engineering with a few programming classes. (I was a CE major.)
- jrockway 16y agoIt really is like the difference between a degree in physics and being a car mechanic. You can be a great car mechanic without a degree in physics, but the intent of the physics degree isn't to create great car mechanics. But in the case of programming, it's the opposite. Computer Science is a subset of what you need to know to be a programmer.
- pwim 16y agoI'm missing your point. Physics is also a subset of what you need to know to be a mechanic.
- baguasquirrel 16y agoDo you need to understand what a metric tensor is in order to be a mechanic?
- sprout 16y agoFrankly I don't think either of them have taken CS, and have no idea what the word subset means. Though I think pwim may have been pointing that out. There are elements of each discipline that overlap, but you don't need to know any of the physics/mechanics pieces that overlap to get a degree in one, and the same is true of CS/programming. In fact, you can be an excellent programmer and know no CS, be an excellent mechanic and know no physics, and even be an excellent computer scientist and know nothing that would serve you in a modern programming job. (Obviously you could probably figure it out, but a code monkey would do just as well as some computer scientists.) But fundamentally they serve different purposes. It's almost conceivable someone could prove P=NP without writing a line of code. Though decreasingly so as computers become so ubiquitous.
- kenjackson 16y agoInterestingly, one of the most brilliant theoretical computer scientists I know only recently wrote his first computer program. Another very well-known,although now deceased, theoretical computer scientist didn't even use a computer. He would have his secretary print his emails and he would handwrite replies and give them to his secretary. Not sure how he wrote his papers, as he was prolific in his prime... maybe the typewriter?