3 ms·
There are few things I hate with more passion than I do the Linux "Graphics Stack." I realize that it inherited a toxic culture from UNIX (remember the X/Motif/
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
There are few things I hate with more passion than I do the Linux "Graphics Stack." I realize that it inherited a toxic culture from UNIX (remember the X/Motif/xNews/Suntools/Etc wars? I do.) and even today there is active warfare in the stack Wayland vs Xorg, GTK vs QT, Gnome vs KDE vs *desktop, HW Vendors vs FOSS, OpenGL vs OpenGL, Etc.
<rant> A great example of this is how broken the simplest of things can be. I've got sitting next to me machine which refused to boot into a "good" graphics configuration, it boots with a 'safe' default of 1024 x 800 screen (where the actual screen is a 2K screen) even though it has HDMI (which can tell it all that it needs to know.) Using a widely deployed nVidia card and the current 'non-free-non-FOSS' nVidia graphics stack. Re-install the driver package, and it works (until reboot). Yes, there is a knob somewhere that screws it up, there are a billion knobs, from a dozen layers, is it DRM/KMS? is it Lightdm? is it Nvidia? Is it OpenGL? Is it a friggin boot option buried in the boot args? It can be anywhere and its going to take me a few hours to figure out where it is. Which in terms of wasted salary time is enough for me to buy a Mac Pro or a Windows box which works every time all the time. </rant>
- Something1234 9y agoWhere can I read about the old war you described?
- ChuckMcM 9y agoThe comp.graphics archives? Mostly that war was fought on mailing lists and Usenet newsgroups of the day. The Open Software Foundation (aka OSF aka Oppose Sun Forever :-)) instigated the Motif war as I recall. SGI, Microsoft, nVidia, S3, and 3DFx instigated the hardware vs FOSS wars armed with PMDs (Patents of Mass Destruction :-).
- nice_byte 9y agoI will never forget the day I decided to dive down that rabbit hole, to get some OpenGL rendering working in a Qt app. I will never look at Linux OpenGL apps the same way again.
- mixmastamyk 9y agoTry booting with the latest ubuntu/fedora live cd to see if it is a problem with your install. I've had good results blowing away an old install, while preserving /home.
- ploxiln 9y agoIt's the nvidia card. The binary drivers are good for 3D acceleration, but bad for system integration. The open source drivers are not good enough. Intel and AMD graphics have much better open source drivers (but are not as good at 3D acceleration).
- vetinari 9y agoThe current AMDGPU driver is quite good, actually. Better at 3D accel than the proprietary one.
- digi_owl 9y agoIMO this comes down to people from the DEs "diving the stack" in some silly attempt at fixing a problem most people didn't have.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoAnd for the curious it was that the nvidia framebuffer kernel module was loaded after the default vga framebuffer module so that first module took precedence.