7 ms·
And AS3/FLex is still better then JS/and any JS framework
by simion314 9y ago
And AS3/FLex is still better then JS/and any JS framework
- whatever_dude 9y agoNot sure I agree. If you use some of the good transpiling languages that output JS, the syntax is far better than what AS3 had. In TypeScript/Flow, for example, you get "real" generics syntax while in AS3 you had the magic Vector<> stuff and that's it. And on top of that you have union types, dynamic interfaces, etc. And thanks to JavaScript VM performance, running the same code is ahead of what the Flash VM could do. AS3 was way ahead of its time when introduced, but browsers have moved past it since it stopped evolving. Flex vs frameworks is more of a matter of preference and contextual requirements so I can't comment on that.
- simion314 9y agoI do not disagree, but the comparisons are not fair,first though , I am not advocating of people building new stuff with Flash so I am not trying to convince you to use it in present day. -comparing a new language TS with the old AS3 is not fair, when AS3 was around TS was not yet here, also AS3 is compiled and in theory games that are well coded in AS3 should be faster -comparing new js frameworks and libraries that are not built-in to the platform with built in Flash/Flex feature is not fair, we should compare the built-in stuff in the browser vs built-in stuff in Flash/Flex , and if we add frameworks for html/js then there are frameworks that people used for Flash/Flex. P.S. If I had a choice in what tools to use in a new SPA I would chose today TS and React(or something like react), if you have experience with React are there good components already built, I mean good that are not buggy(dropdowns going offscreen, or if you have more then one component things go crazy), sometime back when I checked there were only basic stuff and wrappers for jQuerry quality ones.
- whatever_dude 9y ago> comparing a new language TS with the old AS3 is not fair Sure, but that's the comparison invited when one says that AS3 is still better than what's out there today.
- pier25 9y agoAmen. AS3 is one of the best languages I've ever used. Easy to use, dynamic but also statically typed when you want it with many of features from Java and C# which still aren't available in JS. I wrote this a couple of months back: https://medium.com/@Pier/ecmascript-4-was-too-ahead-of-its-time-799e59232db0 https://medium.com/@Pier/ecmascript-4-was-too-ahead-of-its-t...
- simion314 9y agoAs others said Adobe is at fault here, same as Microsoft is at fault of not open sourcing Silverlight and now we end up with html5/js mess that was not designed for what is used. Flex4 is really good and after you learn it you get good GUIs that are efficient and that are easy to reuse and much more efficiient then HHTML based GUIs
- tracker1 9y agoIIRC, the format for Silverlight output was well documented, and open. It was a zip file with a manifest, assets and JS. The down side is they didn't get the penetration. Silverlight was FAR closer to what I'd hoped that Flash would have become when Adobe bought Macromedia. Adobe was really pushing SVG before that, and my hope was that flash content would become a zip, with assets and a manifest, where 2D assets were svg, and the tweaning was something similar to CSS. Either could have been adopted. Would still love to see an HTML "package" format that was similar, where the whole content and assets could be downloaded as a single container, and run offline easily like flash could.
- simion314 9y agoSilverlight was not open source though and it was not cross platform either. Having Silverlight/.Net and Flash/Flex/Air open sourced and competing would have been great, as a copmpany I would have made money from the IDEs and tools, why you need to keep it proprietary and then kill it.
- tracker1 9y ago
- disease 9y agoFlex had some good ideas but many things made it a pretty bad experience to work with: Adobe abandoning WYSIWYG editing in Flash Builder, having two ways to do everything (XML and code) made things more confusing than it had to be, and the official components from Adobe generally weren't very good. I much prefer building by own in React. AS3 was awesome for its time but TypeScript has surpassed it in my opinion. After building up components directly in the language with React there's no way I could go back to using Flex.
- tracker1 9y agoI thought the message on Flash vs Flash Builder was a bit confusing.. but it came down to Flash being more for animation tasks, and Flash Builder more for building crud-like apps. There was overlap, but both targeted differing audiences. I did find some object model inconsistencies annoying all the same, and some of the security implications in the early 00's frankly scared me. Even though I worked with it, I disabled it. React + JS is nice, but the animation tooling in Flash itself was second to none. And still better than many options. If I still made a lot of elearning content, I'd be much more upset by the fall of flash.
- simion314 9y agoDo you have WYSIWYG in React? How much it will take you to implement from scratch in React an AdvancedDataGrid ? I also like TS and React is my favorite way of rendering SPAs, unfortunately at my work we are stuck with JS,and angular1 so the fact that there may be nice things but are not built-in into html5/js is a huge issue. Also how can I ask my boss or the other devs to start using X when next year X may be bad or outdated.
- thebouv 9y agoI soooooooo miss AS3/Flex. :(
- Joeri 9y agoI worked extensively with flex, and I think you give it too much credit. Typescript beats AS3, and modern complete frameworks like angular or ember are just as good as flex.
- petetnt 9y agoSame. My first programming job was doing Flex stuff (Adobe Air desktop apps in an enterprisy way) and after that I did tons of Edge Animate work (in an environment where things needed to run in IE9 at best). I am glad those helped me to kickstart my career, but modern JS libraries, frameworks and paragdims are so much ahead what we had then I can only wonder if I have truly forgotten something really magnificient.
- simion314 9y agoWhat JS combination of tools can you use to get similar to Flex, you would have to add a build tool, some JS framework like angular or react+friends then bootstrap or similar to get some basic widgets or pick the widgets you need from the web(ex pick a jQuery advanced calendar widget and wrap it in angular or React , I saw a lot of code that did bad such wrappings that were single use)
- simion314 9y agoTS is a good language that AS3 users would prefer, but it is new, there was Haxe but it does not has a giant behind it. I am not sure what is a good alternative to Flex, React is the one that seems closer because you have a render function that you can implement and you have the markup but you are still missing a collection of built in, good quality components, I see a lot of projects wrapping in angular or React jQuery components(callendars, color pickers), In Flex you had this components and you could customize them with item renderers and you can extend them with inheritance.
- sireat 9y agoIt almost feels like we have regressed. Making simple CRUD SPAs using HTML5/CSS3/JS/whatever frameworks is way more complicated than using AS3 to do the same thing. It all feels like a giant kludge. What have we gained by going into using modern web stack to make application like pages? Perhaps source is shared more freely and code is more "open", but as the React licensing ruckus shows that is not clear cut. We have certainly not gained more consistency over AS3. There really wasn't anything wrong with the idea of flash compiler doing the heavy lifting for app like pages.
- omg_ketchup 9y agoI LOVE VueJS. But you're right- nowhere near as easy as Flex Builder with AS3. I built an app with Flex Builder that got me my first job. The application is still in heavy use every day, and I've never even once had someone report that something went wrong with it.
- joncampbelldev 9y agoI think long term stability is more an indication of your competence as a software engineer than flex builder's stability. not bashing flash/flex though, my first job was making educational flash games. I wish I could be as productive and have as much fun when working in html and js.