4 ms·
This seems like a fairly unproductive way to make your point, because I can only guess what you mean. What I think you mean is that you can be against increase
by epistasis 9y ago
This seems like a fairly unproductive way to make your point, because I can only guess what you mean.
What I think you mean is that you can be against increased margins for corporations, and that's the reason that you're against immigration.
It's a strange strange thing to be against increased margins for corporations, without any other explanation, so I can see why many people would be confused, if that's what you're trying to say.
- tomc1985 9y agoYou're focusing on the wrong part. Increased margins for corporations at the cost of engineer pay. Companies don't need their margins nearly as much as individuals need a higher salary.
- epistasis 9y agoIf that's true then his comment was even less productive than I thought. The commenter didn't even mention the "part" you think I should focus on.
- bluthru 9y agoThat's what I was implying. Corporations can exploit a social issue to drive down labor costs.
- baddox 9y agoStill, I find it odd to argue that engineer pay is among the top priorities of a well-functioning economy. I'm an engineer, and all else being equal I'll take more money (it has its uses), but I certainly couldn't say with a straight face that my country's immigration policy should be based significantly on its effect on my salary.
- tomc1985 9y agoWhy not? Wage competition is a legitimate byproduct of increased immigration
- bluthru 9y agoWhy shouldn't a nation protect its citizens' wages?
- baddox 9y agoBecause it's bad for consumers, innovation, and the overall economy.
- bluthru 9y ago"The overall economy" isn't as important as wages and purchasing power for individuals. Immigration can lead to less competition and therefore innovation. Instead of people from other countries creating services that compete, they get absorbed by multinationals.
- baddox 9y agoI don't see how higher wages for engineers will lead to more innovation. Can you explain that?
- Bartweiss 9y ago> It's a strange strange thing to be against increased margins for corporations Is it? I know a lot of leftists who consider corporate profit margins something to intrinsically oppose. I mean, they're concerned about the consequences of those margins, but they do think the consequences are inescapable - they think rising corporate margins inherently make the world a worse place. And yeah, that's historically driven an anti-immigration streak among labor movements, made stronger when it's not about new citizens but people operating under alternate labor laws. The deBoer type leftists of today don't carry that xenophobia, but some of them definitely still complain about H1B as a corporate subsidy. It's not a position I endorse (if anything, I'd argue for "strengthen the bargaining position of H1B workers"), but I don't think it's terribly uncommon. I agree that the comment framing is inflammatory and unnecessary, but I wasn't surprised by the part about margins.