2 ms·
As a few others have already noted, this is also an issue of interest in New York. Here's a dataset of privately-owned public spaces from NYC's data portal: ht
by danso 9y ago
As a few others have already noted, this is also an issue of interest in New York. Here's a dataset of privately-owned public spaces from NYC's data portal:
https://nycopendata.socrata.com/Housing-Development/Privately-Owned-Public-Spaces/fum3-ejky https://nycopendata.socrata.com/Housing-Development/Privatel...
(it's a MDB file of around 275K, so I imagine it just holds point data as opposed to full shapefiles)
One of the most well-known debates over the use of privately-owned public spaces was in 2011 when the Occupy Wall Street movement took over Zuccotti Park:
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/20/opinion/zuccotti-park-and-the-private-plaza-problem.html http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/20/opinion/zuccotti-park-and-...
The relevant part which describes how these spaces come with benefits to the developer, even as the developer is left to come up with "reasonable" rules:
> Among the better spaces is Zuccotti Park. The developer never received a floor-area bonus for the 26,000-square-foot park, although it did receive other valuable zoning concessions. The current owner, Brookfield Office Properties, voluntarily installed trees, seating, lighting and art over the last decade. (It also changed the space’s name from Liberty to Zuccotti Park, after John E. Zuccotti, one of its co-chairmen, creating a personal interest in the park’s quality.)
> Nevertheless, the events at Zuccotti Park highlight the continued inadequacy of the laws regarding privately owned public spaces. Other than the requirement that this space remain open 24 hours a day, the owners were left to promulgate their own rules; the only limit is that they be “reasonable.”
> Until last month, Brookfield’s rules barred skateboarding, in-line skating and bicycling, but said nothing about long-term occupation by any group. New rules, announced Oct. 13, permit passive recreation only and prohibit things like camping and lying down on the ground or benches if it interferes with others. The rules remain unenforced; no one is sure what will happen next.