4 ms·
Why should they be free to allow what they like? I don't know of any culture where there is an assumption that private property is absolute - that's a pretty ex
by vidarh 9y ago
Why should they be free to allow what they like? I don't know of any culture where there is an assumption that private property is absolute - that's a pretty extreme view.
On the other end of the spectrum, though, you will find plenty of examples of cultures - and nation states - where there is a historic assumption that the public good and/or liberty requires substantial restrictions on property rights, on the basis that land is a scarce resource and that while some property rights are necessary, or even desirable for the economic benefits it may bring, other such rights severely restricts the liberty of everyone else by depriving them of access, or actively harms society (e.g. most places place restrictions on carrying out various dangerous activities on your property without appropriate permissions).
For my part, the shock of moving to London (from Norway) where many parks have gates that are locked at night, was something I have still not quite gotten over - 17 years later. It feels oppressive, after being used to open spaces - most parks in Oslo have no gates or fences, and most of those that do have large gaps and any fencing is largely to block specific routes. Part of this is more public lands, part of it is a culture where fencing in semi-public private spaces is largely still seen as offensive restrictions on others freedom, helped by extensive rights of access ("freedom to roam") outside urban areas that gets people used to expect to be free to access open spaces.
To me the idea of liberty in a society with strict property rights makes a total mockery of liberty.
- arethuza 9y agoIn places like Edinburgh it's all a bit complex - there are public parks that are always open, public parks that close at night, Royal Parks that are always open but that have funny rules [e.g. no "commercial vehicles"], large private gardens that are basically private parks and a general right to roam on private land anyway.... (with some common sense restrictions).
- clarkmoody 9y agoI disagree with you and take the extreme absolute property rights view. I believe that only through strong property protections can we experience liberty: when one's ownership in property is secure, then one may plan for the future. Conversely, when one's control of property is subject to the arbitrary whims of the state, then one may not plan for the future, and economic growth is not possible. Many poor nations, for instance, have terrible land title systems, and the land may be taken from you by the local magistrate if you are not the proper color / religion / race or have not paid the proper bribes. Such is not a good environment in which to experience liberty. Sure, your empty field will always be open for the public to play football, but there will never be a factory in that field providing jobs and improving the general prosperity. I won't attempt to tackle "the public good" or "actively harms society" here. (I'm assuming that when you mention property that you mean "outside, unenclosed spaces." Do you also extend your view to the buildings on property? Offices? Private homes?)
- michaelmrose 9y agoMeanwhile as land becomes more scarce as population increases AND ownership of wealth which includes land becomes more concentrated in the hands of the few a shrinking minority will have any liberty by your own definition at all. In the US approximately 60% of households owned their home however of those most are owned by the bank. Only a steadily decreasing fraction are actually owned free and clear by those who reside there. Most of the US is in fact divided among those who will be kicked out next month if they don't make their rent and a higher class of renter who will be kicked out several months later if he doesn't catch up his mortgage payments. Both classes have little savings and may easily be a lost job away from homelessness.
- literallycancer 9y agoI've been to most countries in Europe, but I have only seen large swaths of land fenced off in the UK. So freedom to roam must be working well enough at least somewhere. There are a few legitimate reasons to have fences e.g. to along highways to keep out animals, but there is no reason why there couldn't be a gate every few hundred meters.
- vidarh 9y agoActually most of Europe do not have freedom to roam in the legal sense, though might have more limited forms of it, and customs certainly are for not fencing everything in even when there is not explicit legal right of access. The UK on the other hand does have a legal form of freedom to roam that's very new, but very limited in terms of what is covered, so it affects very little land. Compare to the Nordic countries where e.g. it is actively illegal to e.g. fence in a privately owned forest most places, and barring restrictions on disturbing farm animals or ruining crops you can walk almost anywhere in rural areas, freely pick berries (outside of planted fields), mushrooms etc. even on private land, and even camp without needing to ask permission (but custom is to ask where it is convenient if you want to do so e.g. near a farm). Norway (the others might too, but it's Norway I know about) also have strict legal restrictions on building near the sea and blocking access to beaches etc. to protect public access.
- vidarh 9y ago
- mdekkers 9y agoI agree. I am trying to make the point (badly, it seems) that business will do what business whats to do, if the Government allows them to. We (the people) should be able to direct government as to the things we would or wouldn't like to allow business to get away with. I know this system is broken - I firmly believe that if voting were able to make a difference, it would immediately be made illegal. That is the fight we must fight - that is the root cause of the problem.