5 ms·
Side note - anybody thinking about getting married should look into the financial implications of getting divorced. It shouldn't stop you, but you should at lea
by cageface 16y ago
Side note - anybody thinking about getting married should look into the financial implications of getting divorced. It shouldn't stop you, but you should at least understand you're putting at least half of everything you own on the table and potentially more. I think you don't completely understand marriage unless you've been divorced.
It may just be confirmation bias but I've been thinking about heading off in a much less conventional direction myself so articles like this are welcome.
- dkersten 16y agoOr make sure you understand the intricacies of asset protection and hide as much of your wealth away, out of reach of your ex-spouses lawyers.
- sivers 16y agoStrong asset protection should never require hiding! You should always be able to have all assets fully revealed, and still be protected. Never depend on secrets.
- jacquesm 16y agoThat's so true. The other advice reads like security through obscurity, once the secret is blown (and there are no secrets if there is more than one person involved) the security is too.
- dkersten 16y agoBad choice of words perhaps. I really meant hide it out of reach, not hide it out of sight. Good point though. Actually hiding assets is a terrible form of protection (just as in computing security through obscurity is a terrible means of security). EDIT: Looks like jacquesm can type faster than I :-/
- yef 16y agoMy understanding is that half of everything you earned and bought while married is on the table. Stuff you owned or earned before the marriage is not on the table unless you want it to be. Non-marital property vs. marital property. I'm not a lawyer.
- cageface 16y agoI think it depends on the state but you're right that's how it works in CA. Of course that means that if you're the only one working in a marriage that's half of your 100%. If you get married young you probably won't be starting with much.
- yef 16y agoYup. Presumably the non-earner is contributing something else to the marriage and to the household (like child-rearing). And you'd think that if that person was a total slacker and bad spouse, the court would divide the stuff in favor of the earner. But who knows. I'd want to talk to a divorce lawyer or judge. I just wanted to clarify the common misconception that you can "marry someone and take half of their [existing] stuff".
- cageface 16y agoAnd you'd think that if that person was a total slacker and bad spouse, the court would divide the stuff in favor of the earner. Again I think this varies from state to state but at least in CA considerations like this make zero difference. You split anything acquired during the marriage 50/50. Period. I imagine the intent of this rule is to limit the legal wiggle room and consequently the court costs of a divorce but the first thing they'll tell you is to not even use the word "fair". But you're right that things you owned beforehand remain yours.
- __david__ 16y ago> You split anything acquired during the marriage 50/50. Period. And on top of that the judge that ultimately reviews the case can change the terms even if both parties have agreed to them. Presumably this is to fix the problem of making someone sign to a unfair arrangement under duress. This annoyed me (scared me, really) when I went through my divorce, but ultimately our agreement went through the court unscathed (pretty much just 50/50, though certain things are complicated, like how do you value the dog??).
- mhb 16y agoWhy do people get married? It's a poorly defined contract with ill-defined consequences into which they enter apparently because it's what everyone else does to signal their feelings. Similar to giving a diamond engagement ring or using off-the-shelf business forms.
- bigsassy 16y agoBecause your relationship has reached a point where you're both sacrificing a LOT just to be together. You're planning the rest of your life with the idea that she (or he) will be a part of it. Why? Because you're in love and you wouldn't want a future without the other person. So why get married? Because you don't want the other person to be capable of throwing all of your sacrifices away on a whim just because you hit a rough patch.
- cageface 16y agoSo why get married? Because you don't want the other person to be capable of throwing all of your sacrifices away on a whim just because you hit a rough patch. Not sure this is really HN fodder but since we're on the subject. That you give two almost completely diametrically opposed reasons for marriage says a lot about the schizophrenia of the institution. Marriage is simultaneously an expression of love and solidarity and a business contract with the potential for extremely stiff penalties in breach. It's the ultimate "trust but verify" of human relationships. The longer you ponder this the stranger the whole idea seems.
- tome 16y agoIt's a contract that allows you to express love and solidarity, knowing that it's unlikely[1] it'll all be thrown away some point later down the line. [1] Becoming much more likely these days!
- ars 16y agoYou are not marrying another person. You are marrying the other half of YOU. And not your better half either, simply your other half. It's not about love either. Love (as commonly used) lasts 3 years. Don't marry for love or you'll get divorced in 3 years. There needs to be a deeper, quieter, but more constant emotion.
- pkaler 16y agoAsk your lawyer about Family Limited Partnerships. Don't own anything yourself. It's better for tax and estate reasons. And agree up front how assets are split if their ever is a divorce.
- protomyth 16y agoYou might want to also agree upfront on how much is individual versus couple during the marriage. It saves time and hatred when one of you buys a toy.