4 ms·
Your points are excellent, but number 2 seems a weak: why think of it as a single "machine"? If that's the metric, dual- and quad-processing machines would co
by nkurz 16y ago
Your points are excellent, but number 2 seems a weak: why think of it as a single "machine"? If that's the metric, dual- and quad-processing machines would counter any advantage.
Plus or minus some overclocking, a GTX280 and a Core i7 960 both consume roughly the same number or watts (130 for the processor vs 200 for the card?) and cost roughly the same (at least they did when I bought comparables). So while you can stick (and probably should) stick multiple cards in the same machine, it seems a little silly measure this in terms of multiples of single CPU performance.
NVidia's blog response is interesting, and the some of the comments are actually worth reading:
http://blogs.nvidia.com/ntersect/2010/06/gpus-are-only-up-to-14-times-faster-than-cpus-says-intel.html http://blogs.nvidia.com/ntersect/2010/06/gpus-are-only-up-to...
To me, the interesting question here is the degree to which the code has been optimized in each case, and the difficulty of doing so. A while ago there was a competition to attempt to generate SHA1 hash collision: http://www.engineyard.com/blog/2009/programming-contest-and-the-winners-are/ http://www.engineyard.com/blog/2009/programming-contest-and-...
The GPU's trounced every other approach. I participated in the contest minimally (running slightly tweaked versions other people's code on both an Nvidia GPU and a Core i7) and I was amazed at how much more efficient the GPU solution was. I don't recall the exact ratios, but 'orders of magnitude' was definitely not an exaggeration.
But that's sort of a contrived example. So what I'd love to see here is a framework that incentivizes each side to come up with their best solution to some real world problem. My instinct is that there are definitely problems for which 100x is realistic. Knowing which problems these are (and aren't) would be a more effective 'debunking' than a one side proclaiming an 'average' result.
- jacquesm 16y agoI think of the GPU as an 'extra', not in place of, so whatever advantage a regular CPU has you always get more bang for the buck by adding one or more GPUs to a machine, assuming your workload is a good match. If not then it's money thrown away. True that dual and quad processor machines would work even better, but there too it is extra, and especially quad machines are not nearly as cheap as adding GPU cards, CPUs get more expensive quickly as the number of CPUs on the motherboard increases. Personally I'd like to see research like this come out of different corners than either Nvidia or Intel. For those jobs that I used GPUs for (image recognition) they outperformed the CPU on the same task better than 50 to 1, the trick is to keep communications down to a minimum and maximize your use of GPU memory. And that's a lot easier said than done, not all of it is intuitive.