3 ms·
> I didn't realize you were anti-UBI altogether. I'm still not sure where you're getting these conclusions about what my position is, especially when I say thi
by klodolph 9y ago
> I didn't realize you were anti-UBI altogether.
I'm still not sure where you're getting these conclusions about what my position is, especially when I say things like "I'm interested in UBI" which contradict it. If you have a question about my position just ask, if you don't care then don't respond, but I feel like I'm talking to Eliza.
What we seem to agree on is that "just give citizens money" doesn't work.
> And you believe the current welfare complex is superior?
Superior to what? It's hard to even compare something that exists in all its complexity with something that is just an idea you could write down on a napkin. How do you even evaluate a UBI proposal that doesn't have numbers in it?
One complaint here is that people who currently receive SSI should not be dropped by the new system. Rules like "you must be a US citizen for 18 years" are simply unworkable.
> however, I don't think the financial effect of a UBI creates this unlivable economy you describe, and it provides a bright future to look forward to.
It's already hard to be an immigrant, such a system would mean that immigrants get paid significantly less than non-immigrants. I am not interested in a system that deincentivizes immigration that severely. And again, it's hard to evaluate the potential effects a proposal without numbers or quantitative analysis, so I can merely say "I disagree" here and there's not much substance available to change my mind.
One thing to watch out for in these threads is that sometimes people will dismiss or devalue viewpoints or arguments merely because they do not provide alternative solutions to complex problems. That behavior is nothing more than a transparent attempt to shut arguments down without responding to their content.