2 ms·
My take on the Chinese Room: it is a failed mental experiment. CR differs from humans by embodiment - namely - humans are agents in an external world, with cert
by visarga 9y ago
My take on the Chinese Room: it is a failed mental experiment. CR differs from humans by embodiment - namely - humans are agents in an external world, with certain limitations, such as need for food, shelter and avoiding pain and injury, which a room doesn't have. Thus the CR can't learn the same value system as a human. The CR has nothing on the line, humans have the protect their life.
By removing the world itself from the CR, it is limited in its growth. The world allows for exploration and testing of hypothesis.
The CR can't self reproduce, humans can - and reproduction brings a whole list of new constraints for humans that guide evolution. Genetic evolution is also a meta-learning algorithm that the CR lacks. Humans are born with a set of instinctive values which guide the evolution of the brain - like a program. CR has no such initial values (reward channels) and more generally, the problem of learning in CR is glossed over.
Searle should have compared humans with a frail robot that has to earn its electricity and raw materials to produce spare parts by its own endeavor, and be able to learn from and teach its knowledge to other robots. Such a robot might have a closer to human perspective on the world, being embodied and subject to limitations that force it to learn intelligent action.
- red75prime 9y agoThe problem is not differences between Chinese room and human. The problem is in different perceptions of them. One is intuitively perceived as conscious, other not so much. If you can't perceive something as conscious because you see all the moving parts, it surely isn't, right? I see this as "what we can program is not a mind" taken to the extreme.