5 ms·
Yeah, but it fails at its objective when considered outside a European context.
by emodendroket 9y ago
Yeah, but it fails at its objective when considered outside a European context.
- chch 9y agoThat's one of the things I like about the auxiliary language Interlingua[1] over Esperanto[2]. To quote from Wikipedia: "Interlingua has detached itself from the movement for the development and introduction of a universal language for all humanity. Whether or not one believes that a language for all humanity is possible, whether or not one believes that Interlingua will become such a language is totally irrelevant from the point of view of Interlingua itself. The only fact that matters (from the point of view of Interlingua itself) is that Interlingua, thanks to its ambition of reflecting the cultural and thus linguistic homogeneity of the West, is capable of rendering tangible services at this precise moment in the history of the world. It is by its present contributions and not by the promises of its adherents that Interlingua wishes to be judged." It was created with a goal of taking its structure and vocabulary from other common European (mostly Romance) languages, which means if one is familiar with those languages, they can already decently read Interlingua. The same passage from above, for those who might know some Romance language: "Interlingua se ha distachate ab le movimento pro le disveloppamento e le introduction de un lingua universal pro tote le humanitate. Si o non on crede que un lingua pro tote le humanitate es possibile, si o non on crede que interlingua va devenir un tal lingua es totalmente indifferente ab le puncto de vista de interlingua mesme. Le sol facto que importa (ab le puncto de vista de interlingua mesme) es que interlingua, gratias a su ambition de reflecter le homogeneitate cultural e ergo linguistic del occidente, es capace de render servicios tangibile a iste precise momento del historia del mundo. Il es per su contributiones actual e non per le promissas de su adherentes que interlingua vole esser judicate." [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interlingua https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interlingua [2] Not that I've actually studied either, for full disclosure.
- emodendroket 9y agoYeah, I can basically understand texts written in interlingua.
- bshimmin 9y agoI can understand the above paragraph too (from a background in English/Italian/Latin/school-level French), but I can't say there's anything beautiful about it!
- emodendroket 9y agoBeauty isn't really the goal here.
- BoiledCabbage 9y agoAt that point you might as well just speak a Spanish/Italian mashup.
- emodendroket 9y agoI mean, yes, that's basically what this is but it tries to go for words that are in at least 3 (I think?) romance languages.
- geofft 9y agoI learned French in high school and not Spanish (thanks to growing up in southern Louisiana), and I can't read Spanish or Italian texts unless I'm extraordinarily lucky about vocabulary, but I can read Interlingua just fine. I suspect I'd be hopelessly lost in an ad-hoc mashup of Spanish and Italian, but Interlingua is pretty good about constraining vocabulary to things that are usually obvious to a speaker of any Romance language and not adopting shifts that have only taken place in one / a few languages.
- cabalamat 9y agoThis has been done, it's called Interlingua (de IALA, to disambiguate it from the other conlang csalled Interlingua).
- int_19h 9y agoFor the curious, there's a similar take on Slavic languages called Slovio. http://www.slovio.com/ http://www.slovio.com/
- ajuc 9y agoYeah, there were many such attempts in Slavic world. It gives you uncomfortable 80% understanding, while just speaking your own languages gives you like 60% between most pairs. Not good enough to make people use it.
- int_19h 9y agoFrom my personal experience as a native Slavic speaker in other countries, this doesn't work well across groups - i.e. if my language is East Slavic, and my interlocutor speaks West or South Slavic, we can't really get far; certainly nowhere even close to 60%. But, yes, with English being the de facto standard, these more localized attempts are becoming redundant - you want to know English anyway because you want to talk to more people, and once you know it, you might as well use it to talk even to people whose languages are related to yours.
- ajuc 9y agoI'm Polish, and with Slovaks, Belarussians, Ukrainians it's more than 60%. With Czechs it's maybe 50% cause of their pronounciation, with Russians it's maybe 40-50%, because they have weird word roots. Maybe it's because I'm vaguely aware of the phonetic changes between east and west Slavic languages (ić - it, ska - skaja, etc), because I've heard some Russian and Ukrainian on street markets in 90s. Haven't had much experience with other Slavic speakers, but Serbian sounds quite close to western Slavic from the songs I've heard.
- FRex 9y agoThere is also Interslavic that continues from Old Church Slavonic: http://steen.free.fr/interslavic/ http://steen.free.fr/interslavic/ I natively know Polish and I know some very little Russian back from high school and Interslavic is more clear to me than Slovio. I'm interested in linguistics so during one CS conference in Zagreb I asked a few Czechs, Croats, Slovaks, Slovenians, one Belarusian (native in Russian actually but he knew some Belarusian) and back in Poland a few Poles who know only Polish and the results were quite mixed. It really might be better to just treat this as a curio and speak your own (especially in your own West/East/South Slavic language subgroup) and hope for the best. Or just speak English...
- colanderman 9y agoWhy do you say that? Esperanto has actually been relatively successful in Asia (as the article details). Yes, its grammar and lexicon are unrelated to any east Asian languages, but it is nonetheless easy to learn, to the point that it is sometimes used pedagogically as a "first European language" in Chinese universities.
- emodendroket 9y agoIn the sense that it is way easier for native speakers of Europeans to learn than for native speakers of languages such as Asian languages I don't think it actually succeeds in the goal of decolonizing, if you will, the lingua franca.
- SerLava 9y agoWell, Chinese is a very cool language but it's awful for keyboard input and the like. Ideally we'd use a language with an alphabet that also isn't tonal.
- FRex 9y agoWhat's wrong with Chinese input using a decent IME actually?
- emodendroket 9y agoIt's much slower than a skilled alphabetical typist can do. In Japanese, and I assume also in Chinese, there is a faster system used by people who do jobs that require fast typing, but it's very complicated and most people do not learn it.
- FRex 9y agoWhat is that Japanese system?
- 9y ago