3 ms·
For what it's worth, I think this piece is mostly right, especially in pointing out the lack of recognition that our current society does not generally "accept
by uylishist 9y ago
For what it's worth, I think this piece is mostly right, especially in pointing out the lack of recognition that our current society does not generally "accept that education and merit are two different things."
I think there's more to the criticism of a meritocracy, namely that randomness plays a large role in opportunities and demonstrations of success, but the focus of the linked piece is also part of it.
The example of performance of surgeons in medical school is kind of ironic, given studies showing that grades in medical school only weakly correlate with real-world performance. The later mention of ability-chess performance correlations is actually not that different from grade-performance correlations across a range of educational levels.
Not too long ago, there was a job ad posted here that kind of underscored many of these sorts of criticisms, essentially suggesting they were only interested in people from the most prestigious schools. The implication, of course, was that this corporation was not interested in your actual professional achievements or ability, but only the status of the school you attended (which is related at least earlier in life, but not in general).
The example of the person with the degree that's discussed in the piece is also an excellent one, that arises many times. A better example are companies requiring administrators to have master's degrees for its own sake, even if this is not actually required for the job duties. I've seen countless examples where corporations require master's degrees, and actually do not care what they are, which raises the question of why the degrees are actually being required, above and beyond the obvious question of what the job duties actually entail.
Meritocracy has its own problems, related to randomness in events and outcomes, but I think the more immediate problem the linked piece discusses might be better labeled credentialism.
I think it's tied to broader trend toward increasing laziness on the part of corporations and institution in their hiring practices. Maybe it's not laziness, but rather, a sign of regulatory capture, or gross inequality, in that there is such an imbalance in the number of qualified individuals and the number of jobs that employers have to start using criteria that are only tangentially related to the job to filter out applications (e.g., I have 50 people who could actually do this job well, and don't want to admit my choice at this point is actually random, so I'll start selecting them based on unrelated, or only very weakly related criteria).
- tomjen3 9y agoFrom a hiring managers perspective, there is also the benefit that a person who has gone through college is a safe choice that it unlikely to reflect badly on them.