2 ms·
I don't disagree with the point that the article significantly overstates the facts. But calorie restriction has been extensively studied in many species, not j
by wahern 9y ago
I don't disagree with the point that the article significantly overstates the facts. But calorie restriction has been extensively studied in many species, not just rodents. I don't think there's much evidence to say that there's no benefit if you start late, even in rodents; just that the earlier the better, and how much better depends on the species. There's some recent evidence that suggests the opposite (starting too early has no additional benefit) in primates,
Comparative analysis reveals that eating less beneficial in
adult and older primates but is not beneficial for younger
animals. This is a major departure from prior studies in
rodents, where starting at an earlier age is better in
achieving the benefits of a low-calorie diet.
-- http://news.wisc.edu/calorie-restriction-lets-monkeys-live-long-and-prosper/
Also, I think once the conversation turns to specifics like autophagy or especially hand-wavy stuff like "regenerating the immune system" (as in the topic article), the hard facts are already in the rearview mirror.