9 ms·
>the widespread belief that they are virus-free, Macs aren't immune from invasive and dangerous malware. This is an area where it's really hard to extrapolate
by epistasis 9y ago
>the widespread belief that they are virus-free, Macs aren't immune from invasive and dangerous malware.
This is an area where it's really hard to extrapolate from my personal experience to the entire population, but is this really an accurate statement of many people's beliefs?
I think what people actually think is that the chances are much lower of encountering malware in the wild on a Mac. In support of that, having an article this long on a single piece of malware that isn't particularly damaging, would indicate that it's not the normal state of affairs in Mac land.
I would similarly expect that the chances of drive-by malware on Linux are tiny, perhaps even less common than on a Mac, and thus it would be newsworthy if there were some widespread (in relative terms) Gnome malware, or similar.
It's one thing to think that it's uncommon, and another to think that it's impossible.
- digi_owl 9y agoI think it is a holdover from the early Mac days, where a large part of the base OS was in ROM. Thus a simple reboot would clear out any infection. That, and over time the lack of a general market presence, is likely what lead to the belief (never mind that Apple pushed the message with their I'm a Mac ads).
- 80211 9y agoThe early mac days when there was no hard-disk, maybe. But if you inserted another floppy when the virus was in-memory, it would spread!
- tedunangst 9y agoIt's been a few years, but the "I'm a Mac and I'm a PC" ad series talked up virus immunity quite a bit. I suppose one could argue that "don't get malware" was narrowly accurate in the sense that it wasn't presently happening, but there was a strong suggestion of "can't get malware" too.
- coldtea 9y agoIt was presently, and it's easy much happening now either. All these "viruses", or 99% of them, are just trojans.
- mikejmoffitt 9y agoThat doesn't really matter, as to the layperson virus often is a general catch-all term for malware.
- 80211 9y agoRight. The Mac Zealots will say "These aren't viruses! They're unwanted programs purposefully installed by the user who thought he was updating Acrobat." But it's like a 2nd amendment advocate trying to win an argument by pointing out that word "Assault Rifle" is meaningless. It may be true, but it's not a way to argue.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoI'm pretty sure "assault rifle" [0] is a reasonably well-defined term and you mean "assault weapon" [1] in your post. Pointing out that "assault weapon" is meaningless is trying to combat emotive, irrational legislation based on conflating "assault weapon" with "assault rifle" because most people don't understand the difference (and one of the terms was chosen to be intentionally confusing). [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assault_rifle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assault_rifle [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assault_weapon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assault_weapon
- 80211 9y agoYou completely misunderstand my point. I'm a card-carrying NRA member, but I wince when I hear someone notice that a anti-2nd-amendment zealot mixes up terms like "magazine" and "cartridge" and thinks "Aha! I've won this argument because you don't know what these basic terms mean." It really doesn't help convince people on the other side to consider another point of view. In fact, your zealous answer proves my point. Now back to viruses and PUPs.
- horsawlarway 9y agoI would say it is accurate. I doubt most users really think it through, and Apple went out of their way to enforce the idea that Macs don't get viruses in their advertising campaigns around 2010 to 2012. Most users just don't think about it much, and the only exposure they got was ads telling them the thing doesn't get viruses, which Apple finally stopped doing in 2012 after have a very uncomfortable year... https://www.wired.com/2012/06/mac_viruses/ https://www.wired.com/2012/06/mac_viruses/ If you're here talking on HN, then yes, you probably fall into the category of folks who properly understand that uncommon != impossible. I sincerely doubt the vast majority of users make that jump.
- epistasis 9y agoFrom that article: >It may have been technically accurate that Macs don’t get gummed up with PC viruses, but the implication that Apple is virus-free is certainly misleading. But that "implication" is an assumed implication that I haven't seen play out in my non-tech friends. I always thought that stories like those were just drummed up by anti-virus vendors to make sure that people continue buying their wares.
- threeseed 9y ago> I always thought that stories like those were just drummed up by anti-virus vendors to make sure that people continue buying their wares. Look at this article and every article about Mac viruses. Always an anti-virus vendor.
- kbenson 9y agoJust because the people alerting you to something have a vested interest in you being alerted, that doesn't make them wrong. It's good to know the incentives behind actions, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't look at the facts in each case and come to an informed decision.
- coldtea 9y ago>I think what people actually think is that the chances are much lower of encountering malware in the wild on a Mac. Yes -- and what people believe is also true. It's indeed much lower, to the point of being a non-issue almost. (And it's not due to "lower market share" either. Mac OS 7/8 etc had even lower market share than today's Macs have, and it had tons of viruses).
- 13of40 9y ago> Mac OS 7/8 etc had even lower market share than today's Macs have, and it had tons of viruses That's not a valid comparison. When Mac OS 7/8 was mainstream, it was common to get software via a floppy disk that had already been in 10 other machines or from a fly-by-night BBS. Nowadays software distribution is far less peer-to-peer, and it's much more difficult for simple viruses to move from machine to machine. > market share If it's not market share, then what is it? The vast majority of malware attacks happen via social engineering, not zero day vulnerabilities, and the only requirements for that are a gullible user and a computer capable of running unsigned software. Edit: Since I don't have access to a disposable Mac, just out of curiosity, what happens if you torrent something like "photoshop for mac full edition (cracked)" and try to install it? On a PC, assuming you make it through the hurricane of warnings Windows tries to throw in your way, this will almost certainly result in malware getting installed on your computer. What mechanism prevents this on a Mac?
- Retric 9y agoOver the history of Malware I suspect the largest vector was simply machines connected to the internet. Going back to the OS 7/8 days is kind of irrelevant because worldwide computer adoption was so low. So, for the average person what they are going to remember is the unpatched exploits / zero day attacks simply because they affected vastly more people.
- coldtea 9y ago>That's not a valid comparison. When Mac OS 7/8 was mainstream, it was common to get software via a floppy disk that had already been in 10 other machines or from a fly-by-night BBS. Nowadays software distribution is far less peer-to-peer, and it's much more difficult for simple viruses to move from machine to machine. That doesn't make sense. The software that back in the day would be in a disk that had "already been in 10 other machines", can now come from a website that serves millions of machines with the same malware infected programs.
- Semaphor 9y agoMy experience with tech illiterate people is that they think they can't get viruses on Mac or iOS. Viruses are a Windows-only thing in their minds.
- taurath 9y agoI would guess many 20-somethings have recommended a mac to their parents with this as one of the bullet points. At a time, it was more or less true - when dropping a virus on your windows PC was as easy as loading a malicious activex website, macs just didn't even have it. Not to say macs weren't vulnerable, but the attack surface was lower and the cost/benefit to people trying to bot-net your mom's Mac was higher than everyone's unpatched Compaq running Win98.
- 80211 9y agoI'm a 50-something and my Mom with her Mac manages to get infected with browser-based malware. And she's pretty careful. But sometimes those "update" notifications look real to her.
- tracker1 9y agoI used to have to clear out malware remotely from one of my grandmother's computers about twice a year, for several years.. I was so happy when it finally died, bought her a chromebook, which she was very happy with. Chromebooks are probably the single best option for a computer with a keyboard. I wish the chrometops were a bit more compelling, as I'd probably switch my other grandmother (ubuntu 16.04) over. She has one program she plays a lot (since 1996) which runs under WINE.
- threeseed 9y agoI take it she isn't on a recent OSX version ? Because those apps shouldn't be able to be opened unless the author has code signed them. In which case if they are malware then just report it to Apple and they can centrally block the app.
- 9y ago
- NelsonMinar 9y agoPeople think Macs are virus-free because Apple spent years telling them were. Example ad, with John Hodgman as the Windows guy with a virus. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M3Z386vXrt4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M3Z386vXrt4
- threeseed 9y agoThis notion existed far before that ad came out. It's a combination of a few things: (1) why bother investing time and resources for a platform with around 10% of users and (2) OSX has had strong security mechanisms e.g Gatekeeper, XProtect, App Sandbox. Windows 10 is much better but unfortunately not everyone is on that OS yet.
- wfunction 9y ago> Windows 10 is much better but unfortunately not everyone is on that OS yet. Implying Windows 8.1 has security problems... what are they?
- freehunter 9y agoEvery OS has security problems, and every new OS incorporates fixes to them. If you're looking for specifics, a quick Google search can help there: http://www.csoonline.com/article/3044089/data-protection/the-best-new-security-features-of-windows-10.html http://www.csoonline.com/article/3044089/data-protection/the...
- andrewflnr 9y agoSome of these: http://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvekey.cgi?keyword=windows+8.1 http://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvekey.cgi?keyword=windows+8.1 though I'll grant most of the ones on the front page at least are basically just "everything from 7 on".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- RandVal30142 9y ago
- draw_down 9y agoIt doesn't matter, tech journos are in love with the narrative of "Mac users think they're better than the rest of us, but they're not!"
- pdeuchler 9y agoWell, what is true is that it's extremely hard to execute arbitrary code without user knowledge on a Mac. Windows has thousands upon thousands of arbitrary code execution bugs where simply opening something like a pdf can allow an attacker to run arbitrary code as a privileged user. There are many defense mechanisms to this that are inherent to the design and implementation of Darwin/Mac OS.
- munin 9y ago> There are many defense mechanisms to this that are inherent to the design and implementation of Darwin/Mac OS. Do you have an example? Beyond the idea of user/root separation, which doesn't really do much for modern single user computers: https://xkcd.com/1200/ https://xkcd.com/1200/
- pdeuchler 9y agoKinda unfair to not let me use the biggest example (DAC/user separation) just because there might be sensitive data with user permissions when we're talking about arbitrary code execution. Even still, such a concept makes privilege execution orders of magnitude harder on * nix systems. POSIX philosophy also prevents the "keys to the kingdom" kind of exploits you can get in windows, many linux exploits are much harder to chain together simply due to this. The * nix networking stack has always been much more mature and robust than the windows stack, although I'll admit that's not necessarily inherent to the design.
- pjmlp 9y agoVirus were invented on UNIX.
- kenferry 9y agoSandboxing. All third party apps in the Mac app store, and many system apps. Safari, Mail, Messages, FaceTime, Calendar, Contacts, Photos, Notes, and Reminders are all sandboxed. I also really like how Gatekeeper ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gatekeeper_(macOS) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gatekeeper_(macOS) ) works – it quarantines documents such as word files, so that on first open you get a dialog pointing out that it's been downloaded. This is great, because you see the dialog very infrequently. I actually pay attention to it when it comes up.
- bdcravens 9y agoI suspect if you went into 100 Apple stores, and asked 100 of the bubbly sales persons with their cute little Apple shirts if Macs can get viruses, you'd get 50%+ to say no.
- onion2k 9y agoDon't Apple stores sell Norton Antivirus? If they do I imagine the response would be far less than 50%, but it'd come with a sales pitch.
- wnevets 9y ago>but is this really an accurate statement of many people's beliefs? yes. Those on hacker news may understand its not true but non-techies say it all the time ever since apple ran those I'm a pc tv spots
- closeparen 9y agoThe operative form of this belief is, "you probably shouldn't buy and install a consumer antivirus product for your Mac like you would with a PC" which is probably still true.
- zamalek 9y ago> many people's beliefs? Apple marketed it as such even until relatively recently. I've personally heard a few people regurgitate that argument. It's probably changing because that marketing worked and the platform became more popular: you don't write malware for a platform that nobody uses.