3 ms·
I find the recent popularity of cryptocurrencies very interesting as I spent a lot of time in 2009^ studying and researching Bitcoin from the academic perspecti
by AndrewKemendo 9y ago
I find the recent popularity of cryptocurrencies very interesting as I spent a lot of time in 2009^ studying and researching Bitcoin from the academic perspective of economics (My undergraduate degree).
In 2009^ I downloaded a BTC miner and had everything set up but then never started the machine because I was running folding@home and thought that was a better use of my distributed compute. Doh!
In my mind you can look at cryptocurrencies, and the idea of blockchain generally, in two ways. Either you evaluate it as how well it acts as Money or what it can do as a distributed ledgering system.
In the former case you need a comprehensive understanding of:
1. The history of money, which comes down to war and politics,
2. A deep understanding of what makes money work in it's three uses (store of value, medium of exchange, unit of accounting)
3. How it forms a scaffold in a modern economy.
The cryptocurrency-as-money perspective fundamentally has no legs, for numerous reasons, but primarily because it has no coercive power behind it enforcing it's use like all other currencies. A few people are trying it but it's no serious contender for legal tender anytime soon.
All of the "coin" that is created in these markets is effectively derivatives trading and should be avoided at all costs in my opinion.
From the digital ledger perspective there seems to be real value in that use case.
^Corrected year
- smaps 9y ago>I find the recent popularity of cryptocurrencies very interesting as I spent a lot of time in 2007-2008 studying and researching Bitcoin from the academic perspective of economics (My undergraduate degree). >In 2008 I downloaded a BTC miner and had everything set up but then never started the machine because I was running folding@home and thought that was a better use of my distributed compute. Doh! The first version of the bitcoin software was released in 2009, the white paper was published in October 2008.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoOk, 2009 then, whenever it was first available. My memory fails me sometimes.
- hello_marmalade 9y agoIt doesn't have to have a coercive power behind it enforcing it's use. It has a natural benefit, which is anonymity (when used the right way). People want to use Bitcoin as a currency. It doesn't need to supplant normal money, just be an addition to it.
- acdha 9y agoIt's dangerous to push anonymity as a benefit of the current implementations: if you make a mistake or traffic analysis links you to any transaction, every transaction you've ever made is de-anonymized. That's a far worse failure mode than cash and it'll take more than a tumbler to fix to the point of confidence.
- hello_marmalade 9y agoI did say "when used the right way". For various activities it allows you to mask your identity while making purchases online far better than the alternative of using your credit card or PayPal or something.
- acdha 9y agoWhat do you define as “the right way” and how hard is it for the average person to follow? Given the high opsec requirements, I think it's irresponsible to advertise an anonymity service which fails in a way which provides an irrevocable public record of every transaction.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoExcept it's not anonymous, in fact it's LESS anonymous than cash, by a significant margin. https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Anonymity https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Anonymity
- dlwdlw 9y agoIf a blog network were driven by a contract that took away credibility tokens when enough fake-news tokens are amassed the token would have actual heft. Currently even a billion dislikes has no heft ad they can be ignored. Initial credibility can be gained via proof of stake like how banks used to be so luxurious. The stake that is most valuable is that which is most flexible and can be converted into other tokens with least hops. That would be USD currently but with other countries growing in power a distributed token recognized by all countries maytaje its place. (It may be adopted rather than designed just like may tourist industries have adopted the dollar) Dollars fundamentally express a combination of values but because it is one token, the resolution of the values blur together. Tokens increase the resolution to kaleidiscope levels at the cost of confusion. Instead of being able to hold onto one type of token with consistent power holders need to constantly evaluate what combination of tokens allows them to trade for what they want with least hops. The USD lost a lot of trust via bailouts and inflation that reduced wealth for the token holders. Fundamentally there was loss of trust in competence. (which can be made up with increased confidence in military ability!) Ethereum is driven by trust in geniuses. Bitcoin is driven by trust in age. Many altcoins are driven by trust in their respective ideas. Interestingly I think the success of coins is all about building trust rather than technicals (though it's so early that the technical implementation is still very important!) The drum of marketing needs to be consistent for a long time but builds exponentially. Bitcoin currently has the most leverage from this perspective but as the earliest coin it may be saddled with too much baggage to get over the core necessary technical hurdles without splintering. (splintering causes it to become new, destroying the built up age trust!)