4 ms·
Jacqui Dillon is an influential person in UK mental health care. This submission starts with a description of her service experience 25 years ago. It's clearly
by DanBC 9y ago
Jacqui Dillon is an influential person in UK mental health care.
This submission starts with a description of her service experience 25 years ago. It's clearly an awful experience.
But it doesn't talk about the things that have changed.
People who report sexual abuse are much more likely to be believed. Things aren't good, but they're much better than they used to be.
There are early intervention in psychosis services in some parts of England. (Regional commissioning mean they don't exist everywhere). These work with people who have a first episode of psychosis.
Very recently there has been a lot of work around perinatal mental health (the Twitter user Rosey - @pndandme runs some Twitter chats and they'd have lots of info about how good / bad services are).
Importantly, mental health teams are multidisciplinary teams. That team would include social workers (who have some statutory duties), mental health nurses, occupational therapists, and a psychiatrist. They'd arrange access to other teams - psychologists, housing advice, debt and benefit advice, employment support, social activity, exercise support. (Not all of these would be "THE NHS"' see of it would be charities or community interest companies or private companies. They should all be free at the point of delivery).
MH Professionals are much more comfortable with "breakout symptoms" - they know that antipsychotic medication has pretty devastating side effects, so they want the patient to be on the minimum needed dose. This might mean that people still have auditory hallucination, but are given support to cope rather than being heavily medicated.
The article suggests that many psychiatrists are only there to prescribe meds. That is an important part of their job (they're the only ones who can prescribe meds), but there are plenty of doctors who fully accept the "bio psycho social" model, and who focus on the psychological and social factors.
The article.makes it sound like none of this is happening.
Also, go careful with Lurhman, there are several critiques of that report.
- dood 9y agoTIL https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biopsychosocial_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biopsychosocial_model thanks.
- dsego 9y agoWhy should we believe reported sexual abuse from someone experiencing a psychotic break? I have a family remember who spent two months in a psych ward last year. They had secretly stopped taking their meds and started practicing some weird form of meditation that triggered vivid recollections of childhood abuse. This culminated in accusing everyone in the family of sexual abuse and even talk about a secret pedophile society in our town. It took heavy doses of anti-psych meds and injections to get them back to reality. Now a year later they don't even mention any of the experiences.
- phkahler 9y ago>> Why should we believe reported sexual abuse from someone experiencing a psychotic break? You should not take it at face value. But neither do I think you should tell them it didn't happen and it's all in their head. The later is telling them there is something wrong with their mind (to shame the patient can be extremely bad practice). Also, if you reject the notion of abuse and it turns out some of it was true, you'd be gas lighting the patient which will lead to additional distress and a distrust of the very people who are trying to help. On a purely speculative note: Perhaps your family member had experienced some of that abuse. Perhaps the stress they were under (and that is a very broad term) lead to those thoughts mixing with all sorts of present day events and people. Whatever the cause, given what they went through to get pulled back to reality do you think they'd ever mention any of it again?
- xxyxx 9y ago>> Also, if you reject the notion of abuse and it turns out some of it was true, you'd be gas lighting the patient which will lead to additional distress and a distrust of the very people who are trying to help. Absolutly true. If you deal with a psychotic it is very hard to convince them it's a delusion. People won't understand the patient and will treat them like an idiot and crazy person. Try to treat the patient and the delusions with respect and at least try to understand the situation. If you dismiss it as "crazy talk" and insult the patient's intelligence you will only make it worse. I suffered for years and it was a neverending nightmare. Nobody will ever understand the horrible things I went through. And the worst part of it all. You get told everything is delusions. No one believes you and you doubt yourself. I will never know what experiences were real and what experiences were only in my mind. And it's really hard. I know some of it was real. But I don't know how much and what. I have the constant feeling everybody is gaslighting me and just wants me to believe I'm crazy through and trough. These days I avoid social interactions and keep to myself. I don't trust people anymore and isolated myself. I read a lot and feeding my brain somewhat intellectual content to keep it busy. It seems to work. I haven't had a major episode in 2 years. Which further confirms my theory, that it was the environment and the people around me. I'm happy when I'm alone and I can relax. But I have the constant feeling that I will never know the truth about my experiences and nobody will ever tell me. My point is never, ever under no circumstances lie to a shizophrenic. Not even If you think you are doing a good thing. Tell the truth, even if it will hurt. Not knowing is really really bad for mental health. And we are not exactly good on social cues, so tell it like it is and don't be subtle. source: I was diagnosed 8 years ago edit: typos