3 ms·
OK, the government might say, here's a wad of money for you to create replacement, so that we don't miss these outside-GFW resources anymore. Of course, the m
by nine_k 9y ago
OK, the government might say, here's a wad of money for you to create replacement, so that we don't miss these outside-GFW resources anymore.
Of course, the money would go to those capable and loyal enough to actually try and make something. It could be used to both decrease the objective dependence on the politically dangerous but important outside-GFW resources, and bring enough rivalry between the less loyal for the access to the government grants to weaken any latent opposition.
As far as I understand, GFW does not block all access; it blocks politically-sensitive access. There's plenty scientific / engineering / whatever resources on the Internet that don't carry political messages, and don't try to. I bet effectively indexing and censoring the outside-GFW internet is a viable task for China's IT. It does not need to be as good as Google; it needs to just be OK to allow the important R&D to continue.
- zhemao 9y agoIt's not just the technical services those platforms provide, but also the content hosted on them and the other users who use them. The article mentions Dropbox and Google Drive. Even if a Chinese file-sharing service was created as a replacement, good luck convincing foreign collaborators to use it. Also blocked are YouTube and Twitter, which are great platforms for promoting your work to a global audience. I just don't see the Chinese government handicapping their researchers this way just for some extra control. What's more likely is they'll work out a deal with trusted universities and corporations to give their employees access to an official VPN through which they can get unrestricted internet access. But all traffic through this VPN will be closely monitored.
- baybal2 9y agoThere is no such thing as an "official VPN"
- nine_k 9y agoI don't see why getting certain videos whitelisted and proxied through an official site or GFW directly would not be viable. Same for twitter: send your tweets via an approved gateway, get them reviewed an pushed to Twitter, get pre-censored retweets as they appear and get approved. Make the international voice of the PRC researchers official-only, Soviet-style. With corporations, it's harder. But for each "we don't trust your servers" from a Western corp side there could be a symmetric "we don't trust your servers" from Chinese side. The resolution depends on who needs the other side more; I bet that in most cases it would be Western corporations giving in.