3 ms·
I never understood why certain female dominated fields like Nursing are excluded from STEM. My mom was a nurse, my sister in law is a NP and my wife is studying
by Spooky23 9y ago
I never understood why certain female dominated fields like Nursing are excluded from STEM. My mom was a nurse, my sister in law is a NP and my wife is studying to be an RN.
It sure looks a lot more like STEM than my "tech" job, which has more elements in common with what my aunt did as a secretary in the 70s than science.
- michaelchisari 9y agoI often refer to most computer programming as "digital carpentry." Of course, there are definitely jobs that require someone be more of an architect or a scientist, but the vast majority of jobs just need someone who can build common things that work and work well. In that sense, most of the programming work I did in the first decade of my career had more in common with the blue collar tradecraft that my father did than it did with anything anyone would consider to be a STEM career.
- weberc2 9y agoAgreed. I always thought of it more as a trade, though now that I've been in the field for a few years, I'm realizing that technical prowess is secondary to political skill. A sub par programmer with excellent political skills will be seen by the organization as more valuable, whether or not he actually is. (This isn't sour grapes, I've been on both sides of the evaluation).
- coolgeek 9y agoPolitical skill can certainly get some people, in some situations, a lot further than they deserve. But technical prowess is absolutely not secondary to political skill in any general sense And you can substitute just about anything else for 'technical skill' in the above sentences and it will still read true
- tzs 9y ago> I often refer to most computer programming as "digital carpentry" Then perhaps it is appropriate that at at least one company, Hughes Aircraft, the union that represents programmers is the United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners of America. That odd situation came about because a whole bunch of union carpenters worked on the Spruce Goose. After that project was shelved many of those carpenters went on to other jobs within the company, but kept the UBC as their representative. As Hughes expanded and also acquired other companies, UBC continued to represent them. In the '70s they made a big effort to organize the rest of the workers, and the result was the UBC ended up representing the majority of Hughes Aircraft workers even though almost no actual carpentry takes place there.
- noobermin 9y agoWell, this article should make you somewhat happy because the author does include it.
- forgottenpass 9y agofields like Nursing are excluded from STEM Health care is a very respectable field in and of itself If you think it matters if nursing is 'part of STEM' you're falling for journo/blogger memes.
- Spooky23 9y agoThe problem is that these lines of thinking have real impact. Schools are measuring their success, looking for dollars and changing curriculums around these memes. We should expose kids to a variety of productive fields. Many people I know were pushed down paths they weren't suited for because of nonsense like this. My aunt was caught up in a "We must get women in business!" thing in the 80s, and ended up spending a long time working for the airlines, which was just a job for her. She went to PT for an injury and discovered this field the never existed, went back to school and became a physical therapist at 50. It's a job she loves and is passionate about -- the only thing she liked about her old gig was helping people. That's not to say it's anyone's "fault". But there's a difference between pushing and exposing. We're pushing as a society. I don't want my son to be an engineer because his dad expected him to me.