3 ms·
This "fire Core" situation reminds me of Uber. You can be killing it 24/7 and still get fired if you cause enough non-technical damage.
by wmf 9y ago
This "fire Core" situation reminds me of Uber. You can be killing it 24/7 and still get fired if you cause enough non-technical damage.
- twblalock 9y agoBitcoin is supposed to be a currency, so there are many non-technical aspects of it that need to be properly handled. If the people working on the code take it upon themselves to make the non-technical decisions too, they need to be held responsible for the outcome. This really gets at the heart of my dislike for cryptocurrency -- most proponents believe it's supposed to be decentralized and free from the control of government, but it's actually centralized under the control of a small group of unelected programmers (who seem to misunderstand how human societies, currencies, and contracts actually work), and there is no recourse when they make bad decisions except to fork the blockchain and the code. It's really a step backwards in terms of governance compared to, say, fiat currency with democratic governance. This applies to most cryptocurrencies I've seen, not just bitcoin.
- icebraining 9y agoIt's not, though; the developers can write the code, but they can't force people to upgrade.
- wmf 9y agoThey can withhold features that people want by refusing to code them, which is what one of the controversies is about.
- vertex-four 9y agoBut other people can code them, and people as a whole can choose what software they want to run?
- twblalock 9y agoIf some large exchanges upgrade, and some don't, the consequences are similar to those of a code fork. Suddenly the currency becomes split into two different currencies.
- ericb 9y agoTake a look at Tezos when it comes out. It tries to solve the governance problem with built-in governance and a system for promotion based on the will of the stakeholders.
- omarchowdhury 9y agoFiat currencies are not under democratic governance. Central banks control them, and you cannot cast a ballot on what your central bank should do.
- RandVal30142 9y ago>You can be killing it 24/7 Problem is they have -not- been killing it 24/7. This block size debate has been going on for years with Blockstream(Core) refusing to do anything about it aside from indirect fixes. Well before Bitcoin's 1MB blocks were full people were getting dismissed/deflected/denigrated due to bringing the subject up to the developers. As the issue climaxed earlier this year Blockstream only proposed SegWit as a fix[1]. Segwit isn't even related to the block size issue directly. It is more applicable to Blockstream's business plans for rolling out for-profit Lightning Network nodes that use Bitcoin as a settlement layer. So for years now Blockstream has done what? Threatened to edit[2] Satoshi's whitepaper while ignoring public consensus unless the public accepts their kludge of a 'fix?' Fire Core. They are overtly driving Bitcoin away from the purpose it was created for, a "peer to peer electronic currency." They halted Bitcoin development after investment by AXA and others, turning their focus into creating for-profit products that use Bitcoin. Fire Core. [1] https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/10028 https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/10028 [2] https://github.com/bitcoin-dot-org/bitcoin.org/issues/1325 https://github.com/bitcoin-dot-org/bitcoin.org/issues/1325