4 ms·

He is correct though. OP used an appeal to nature fallacy. The conclusion is correct, the argument is stupid.

• tentaTherapist 9y ago
  In this case an appeal to nature is not fallacious, although it lacked the appropriate justification.
  • caminante 9y ago
    No, it's still a fallacy. By providing "appropriate justification," it'd no longer be a fallacy.
    • jack9 9y ago
      Isn't a fallacy a false (baseless) justification? I'm not sure how providing justification changes a fallacy.