4 ms·
As someone who has built his own telescope and been somewhat involved in amateur astronomy, this sounds like marketing bullshit to me. It reads like a press re
by CydeWeys 9y ago
As someone who has built his own telescope and been somewhat involved in amateur astronomy, this sounds like marketing bullshit to me. It reads like a press release. The first bullet point is especially damning; it's pure marketing speak devoid of any substance. Aperture diameter matters -- that's the total amount of light available. It's why when you want a better telescope, you go bigger. There's no way around that.
Bullet point #2 is nothing special; it's just using GPS for location and a clock to automatically point your telescope at a specific object. This has been around for a long time.
Bullet #3 appears to be talking about image-stacking, which, again, is a technique already commonly employed -- put your telescope on a computer-controlled equatorial mount, take many 30 second exposures (typically the max allowed by a DSLR) over the course of hours, and combine them in software. And I seriously doubt that you can get much utility out of stacking images taken by different telescopes in different viewing conditions.
- madaxe_again 9y agoAperture isn't just the amount of light, but also resolving power. A small aperture with a long exposure might show you a DSO, but probably at >arcsec resolution. But - this makes it accessible. I don't think you can say the same for pixinsight, dss, phd, etc. - there's a fair old learning curve to do it the proper way.
- CydeWeys 9y agoYes, making the features easier to use is always a good thing of course, and many a company has become a successful player in its field not by inventing new things but by making existing things more accessible. What I don't like about the press release is that it makes it sound like they've come up with all these new revolutions in astronomy, which near as I can tell they haven't done at all.
- breck 9y agoI guess it depends on how you define "revolution". I can clearly foresee how this might lead to 100x more people getting into astronomy. The current amateur experience is to look at the Moon, look at Jupiter, look at Saturn's rings, and then put the telescope in the attic. Once this real-time image-stacking telescope that works just like an old fashioned "dumb" telescope is refined, the experience for amateurs will be so much better. So I would call this "revolutionary", in that if you graphed the # of amateur astronomers, I could see this being a critical non-linear point where the line shoots up at a much faster rate. So a "revolution" for experts? Probably not. (Although perhaps even experts will get a lot out of the speed and simplicity of it). But for astronomy as a field, possibly.
- CydeWeys 9y agoHere's hoping. I'm not quite that optimistic about it as you are, but I'd love to be wrong!
- ttyl0125 9y agoAbout #2 - I think the 'new' part they're touting here is no longer needing to ensure the telescope knows exactly where north and the horizon are. In other words, given a known location from GPS and some images of stars from the builtin camera, it'd be possible to calculate in which direction (az/el) the telescope was pointing. Is there a general term to describe this sort of thing?
- CydeWeys 9y agoSelf-calibration? Automatic alignment? Real astronomical telescopes have been doing that for forever, even by hand since before computers existed. A compass is just never accurate enough (and magnetic north isn't a constant besides). And yes, there are telescopes already available in the thousands-of-dollars range that calibrate themselves by combining data from GPS, the time, and sightings of a few specific stars. See e.g. http://www.celestron.com/university/astronomy/skyalign-(us-patent-no-7,382,448) http://www.celestron.com/university/astronomy/skyalign-(us-p...
- Jedd 9y ago> Aperture diameter matters -- that's the total amount of light available. I think the point is the implied 'at that instant' which can be appended to your statement. Aperture matters in the context of a specific shutter speed. You allude to that 'aperture is everything' loophole in your comment on bullet point #3, about image stacking.
- CydeWeys 9y agoIt also matters for resolving power though. You can take photos using a 1 m telescope with a one second exposure that you could never take using a 10 cm telescope at any exposure length. Keep stacking the photos for years, you're still not going to get the same detail. This is why the latest generation of land-based optical telescopes have truly mind-boggling apertures. Bigger is better in astrophotography, full stop. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extremely_Large_Telescope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extremely_Large_Telescope
- Jedd 9y agoAre you suggesting astrophotography has physical constraints that non-astro photography does not? More specifically, to your example, if a 1m (diameter?) telescope takes a photo with a 1s exposure -- you're suggesting that it will resolve more detail than one taken on a 10cm lens for 100 seconds?
- CydeWeys 9y agoIt's the same across all astronomical telescopes. And yes, resolving power is dependent on the size of the aperture. You can't make it up for it by combining many photographs taken with a smaller telescope. More information here: https://web.njit.edu/~gary/202/Lecture6.html https://web.njit.edu/~gary/202/Lecture6.html
- simonh 9y agoThe resolving power of a 1m scope isn't 100 times that of a 10cm scope. It's 10,000 times as much. Pi d squared. But I think the issue is that with super long time exposures things like lens and mirror aberrations, cumulative drift and rotation over time get magnified as well. As the exposure gets longer, the incremental benefit you get from each unit extension of the exposure decreases. Also, if you take 100x as long to do an observation, that's a hundredth as many observations you can do in any given amount of time.
- agumonkey 9y agoOut of curiosity, have you ever made your own mirrors/lenses ?
- ricardobeat 9y agoApparently it does the equivalent of image stacking in "real time" as you look through the electronic viewfinder - no new tech involved, but a big win in cost/complexity nonetheless.
- maxerickson 9y agoIt literally is a press release: http://www.seti.org/seti-institute/press-release/seti-institute-unistellar-partnership-promises-revolutionize-amateur http://www.seti.org/seti-institute/press-release/seti-instit... Much or all of the content on phys.org is press releases pulled from science related institutions.