4 ms·
A new theory sheds light on the emergence of life’s complexity
- hprotagonist 9y ago>“Red,” for instance, is a translation of the phrase “620-750 nanometer wavelength.” only sometimes.
- kamac 9y agoDo you mean only sometimes, as in only when talking about electromagnetic waves? Or something else?
- munificent 9y agoIt can also mean a sum of wavelengths outside of that range whose average is in the range.
- roywiggins 9y agoAnd the temperature example is even worse. Our subjective experience of temperature is only kind of correlated with what physicists call temperature.
- Odenwaelder 9y agoHere's a better article without the theological nonsense: https://www.quantamagazine.org/a-new-thermodynamics-theory-of-the-origin-of-life-20140122/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/a-new-thermodynamics-theory-o...
- FlashGit 9y agoNever ceases to amaze me how some scientists can embrace a bunch of 2000+ year old nonsense.
- woodandsteel 9y agoThat's a really good article.
- axhue 9y agoVery interesting! I wonder that if they are expecting to use dissipative mechanisms in small system how would they be able to control thermal noise and reproducibility of the calculations?
- medymed 9y agoNot new. Seems like a repost. Also: "This article was originally published in our “Adaptation” issue in March, 2016." Someone is really pushing this guy's scientific (or literary) branding.
- boromi 9y agoYep. Some of the headlines are particularly egregious. https://www.bing.com/news/search?q=%22jeremy+england%22&qs=n&form=QBNT&sp=-1&pq=%22jeremy+england%22&sc=8-16&sk=&cvid=8252C82E770E48B68A879962307562BC https://www.bing.com/news/search?q=%22jeremy+england%22&qs=n... I suspect he is up for tenure review :P His proposals are not knew just spun differently. You can find critics from other physics/chemist regarding their suspicions as well.
- woodandsteel 9y ago> His proposals are not knew just spun differently. You can find critics from other physics/chemist regarding their suspicions as well. I have a rule that people shouldn't post negative comments without including specific arguments and/or links. You just violated that rule.
- rpedela 9y agoMarch 2016 is pretty new, and I am happy for the repost because I didn't see it the first time and it is a very interesting idea.
- mercer 9y agoQuite a few publications re-post older articles, and I vaguely recall Aeon doing so in the past (not 100%). That said, usually they're a bit older than a year or so.
- EGreg 9y agoHeard this before. What do y'all think of this twist on "atheism vs intelligent design" debate? A wild swing from "life is improbable" to "life is almost certain". I think there's some major flaw in this reasoning. Otherwise, how do you explain Drake's equation? How come every planet we have seen so far doesn't have any form of complex life on it so far as we know? Here's what I think the flaw is: the more a planet heats up, the more it can radiate into space as infrared radiation. Obviously an equilibrium can be achieved without a constant increase in complexity.
- JoBrad 9y agoI don't think we have enough data to be sceptical about the presence of certainty of life on other planets. We've only found ~3,700 planets other than Earth - and only ~20 of those are near the size of Earth[0]. We couldn't even see those planets directly until very recently, so it doesn't seem certain (to me, a layman) that we could even identify Earth as having life, at the same resolutions. That's assuming that we would recognize life, if we saw it. (Side note: Children of Men is a book I recently read that touches on this topic. ) I'll admit that I am very optimistic about the presence of advanced life on planets other than Earth, so this is definitely influencing my outlook. [0] https://www.google.com/amp/s/arstechnica.com/science/2016/05/number-of-potentially-habitable-planets-in-our-galaxy-tens-of-billions/%3Famp%3D1 https://www.google.com/amp/s/arstechnica.com/science/2016/05...
- EGreg 9y agoBut we have explored Mars and the moon!
- rpedela 9y agoNot really, not at the level necessary to rule out the existence of life. Both Jupiter and Saturn have moons that may have life based on our current understanding of life and its origins. And Mars may still have life that we haven't found yet. The truth is that we are just now able to start seriously asking the question: is there life elsewhere in the universe? It may take a few hundred years to answer that question.
- j_m_b 9y agoThis theory reminds me a lot of the folding funnel. It used to be thought of as a paradox that a protein could fold in mere minutes if it needed to explore each possible configuration before arranging into its "correct" configuration. This paradox was solved with the theory of the folding funnel (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folding_funnel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folding_funnel) which states that the potential energy surface is not flat, but rather it is 3 dimensional funnel with points where it is practically impossible to go backwards. The nascent protein does not explore the entire potential energy surface, instead it just folds into relatively few transition states before assuming its final form.
- vanderZwan 9y agoThe wiki page still calls it a hypothesis, but also doesn't seem to have had substantial updates in a decade (where I define "substantial" as "an expert updated the information" - not a critique of the other types of edition that have happened). Is there any more recent material on this? An animated visualisation, perhaps?
- tstactplsignore 9y agoI did my undergrad in biophysics and this is basically a simplified version of the currently accepted view. We now also know that some proteins fold in units, and can have multiple stable fold stopping points along the folding paths, and a good deal of proteins never really have a single stable fold at all. Basically google scholar "protein folding energy landscape" for more details. http://m.pnas.org/content/113/12/3159.short http://m.pnas.org/content/113/12/3159.short Here's a nice visualization: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Manajit_Hayer-Hartl/publication/26262477/figure/fig3/AS:272608570638341@1442006356158/Figure-1-Energy-landscape-scheme-of-protein-folding-and-aggregationThe-purple-surface.png https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Manajit_Hayer-Hartl/pub...
- Myrth 9y agoThe next step will be the realization that asymmetry of direction towards self organization on all levels, coded as energy consumption/dissipation efficiency, is a built in property of our reality, and life and counsciousness as we understand then are not random accidents. Quarks -> protons/neutrons, nucleus+electrons -> atoms, atoms -> molecules, molecules -> proteins, proteins -> cells, cells -> organisms, organisms -> ecosystems, stars -> galaxies, galaxies -> clusters, etc.
- pnut 9y agoThere seems to be more of a bell curve of complexity as you move through the powers of ten... Galaxies have some general organizational properties at the very large scale, as do atoms etc at the very small end, but directly in the middle of those extremes lie us, the alchemical pinnacle of self organisation until proven otherwise.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoThis just struck me. As something is becoming organized, something else is becoming disorganized or even failing to exit. We seem to recognize and study the one, but ignore the other. But perhaps there's something to be gleaned from taking the perspective of what's gone, not what is now?