3 ms·
Whether something is a language or a dialect is a political question, not a linguistic one. The Arabic dialects are as varied as the Romance languages in gramma
by barry-cotter 9y ago
Whether something is a language or a dialect is a political question, not a linguistic one. The Arabic dialects are as varied as the Romance languages in grammar and vocabulary.
- uiri 9y agoWhile this is true to some extent, I think the question is mostly one of mutual intelligibility; that is, whether a speaker of dialect A and dialect B can understand each other by each speaking their own dialect. This is obviously a spectrum - there can be no mutual intelligibility at all, some amount of mutual intelligibility (like among some of the romance languages), near full mutual intelligibility, and full mutual intelligibility. So, where the line is drawn depends upon political factors. Despite all of the PRC's claims to the contrary, Chinese is not a single language but a language family. There isn't really much you can do politically when mutual intelligibility is low.