3 ms·
If Bitcoin had been based on "proper" Keynesian economics then the price would probably still be under a cent and no one besides a few cypherpunks would care ab
by wmf 9y ago
If Bitcoin had been based on "proper" Keynesian economics then the price would probably still be under a cent and no one besides a few cypherpunks would care about it. To bootstrap a successful cryptocurrency you need a critical mass of speculators attracted by crackpot Austrian monetary policy. Unless this problem can be solved it will continue to cast a large shadow over the entire concept of cryptocurrency.
- loceng 9y agoThe technology can be developed and then simply it will have to be society en mass to decide when and if we switch over to using it. Perhaps even the global community requiring the adoption at the same time, however nations will likely only want to transition when they are in a better position value wise compared to other nations. I think it could happen.
- wmf 9y agoSociety never decides en masse to switch anything.
- loceng 9y agoNot yet - the internet is fairly recent technology though. Even our voting mechanisms and processes are rudimentary and can greatly improve with things like citizens being able to micro-vote on anything and everything - with policies in place to not flood people with too many decisions, while giving them enough confirmed time (e.g. proof of awareness) to make a decision to allocate a vote to an issue.
- acdha 9y agoVoting is a really hard problem: beyond the massive and likely intractable security problems[1] you start getting into problems with knowledge. Say you push out a vote on a big trade deal or a proposed change to the healthcare system – what percentage of voters have the time and knowledge to even evaluate the options? What percentage of them have time to do so before the deadline? 1. Consider how you'd handle an employer coercing their employees to vote in a particular way. Absentee ballots are already a problem here but they're not used frequently enough to be decisive in most elections.
- loceng 9y agoTo your first problem point - the quick thought I have is to allow people to appoint a person they trust specifically for that. I don't know how it would unfold, however hopefully you'd be able to do research on someone - to see what their character is, how they behave, etc. How would an employer learn how an employee votes? And fuck that shit - with UBI hopefully people early on in life will learn to not tolerate force/pressure and control like that.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoSee Dogecoin for an example of an inflationary cryptocurrency that never went anywhere. Although apparently it's surging again, so who knows. https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/dogecoin/ https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/dogecoin/
- wmf 9y agoAnother thing cryptocurrency people get wrong: Referring to an eventual fixed supply (e.g. 21M BTC) as "deflationary" and an eventual unlimited supply as "inflationary". In reality, deflation means demand is increasing faster than supply and inflation means supply is increasing faster than demand. A cryptocurrency with open-loop monetary policy may be both deflationary and inflationary at different times. Bitcoin and Dogecoin are no different in this respect; they both use open-loop policies that lead to massive volatility. Real-world currencies use closed-loop monetary policy to consistently target a particular level of inlation/deflation, but this is too "boring" for cryptocurrency.
- d33 9y agoWouldn't implementing that mean giving control to a specific party, as opposed to the level of inflation/deflation? How could the system determine it automatically?
- legolassexyman 9y agoIt can't. For example if you target a certain level of money velocity people could just spam large fake transactions and cause inflation. Bitcoin does enable some interesting monetary ideas like demurrage, or constant recycling of the money supply. It also runs "open loop". This is implemented in some super small cryptocoins like Freicoin. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demurrage_(currency) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demurrage_(currency)
- pedrocr 9y agoSome economists have argued for replacing central banker judgment with a fixed function as a way to bring clarity to policy and make the rules fairer. Something like the Taylor rule perhaps: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taylor_rule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taylor_rule