3 ms·
I'm not in favor of this law at all. But when groups use pressure tactics to try to get stores and organizations to boycott Israel, it goes to a whole new leve
by ars 9y ago
I'm not in favor of this law at all.
But when groups use pressure tactics to try to get stores and organizations to boycott Israel, it goes to a whole new level.
And that level is virtually indistinguishable from anti-Semitism. And outlawing that, that I would support.
- madaxe_again 9y agoDiscrimination on religious grounds is already illegal, which would include antisemitism.
- hirundo 9y ago> Discrimination on religious grounds is already illegal, which would include antisemitism. It shouldn't be. If you think that it's unconstitutional to prohibit boycotting a country, you should believe the same about boycotting an individual. I'm a Jew and a Zionist, but I believe that it should be legal to decline to do business with me out of antisemitism. For one thing, it gives me the data that I need to reciprocate.
- fweespeech 9y agoNations and individuals are not equivalent by any reasonable stretch of the imagination. Or do you genuinely think all rectangles are squares as well? Simply because one is a subset of the other does not make the equivalent things that should be treated identically in all circumstances. Permitting individuals to make their choices (i.e. On the basis of religion or any other philosophical belief) without fear of discrimination in a Democracy is critical to the proper function of a Democracy. Otherwise, oppression of minority positions is too easily used to destroy that minority's ability to exercise their franchise. Preventing the boycotting of nation states is not equivalently necessary to the proper function of civilized society. Nations are the outcomes of decisions made by very, very large numbers of people in aggregate combined with centuries of history. Opposing those outcomes are sometimes politically necessary.
- chroem- 9y agoHow is it racist to have reservations about a nation that's implementing a modern and even more violent version of apartheid?
- ars 9y agoYour comment proves my point. Israel is not apartheid at all, the only reason people say that is anti-Semitism. So thank you for proving my point.
- stefantalpalaru 9y ago> Israel is not apartheid at all, the only reason people say that is anti-Semitism. https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Israel_and_the_apartheid_analogy&oldid=774864866 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Israel_and_the_ap...
- maxxxxx 9y agoYou are not helping your case with these statements.
- bootlooped 9y agoThe only point you're proving is that people claim anti-Semitism way more often than is appropriate.
- geek22 9y agoA boycott can be justified if it applies on specific brands, or specific products, or specific ingredients... When it applies on every products based only on their origin, it's ludicrous. When it applies on every products from a democratic country where people just want to live of their production without political interest, it's stupid. When it applies on every products from Israel based on apartheid allegations shouted by BDS, whereas it doesn't apply also on every products of Syria, Iran, Tchechenia... it's antisemitism
- zzalpha 9y ago
- mikeash 9y agoBoycotting Israel is completely different from anti-semitism. Israel and Jews are separate things, and there are more of us outside of Israel than in it.
- ars 9y agoIt can be separate, yes. But in the real world it virtually never is.
- mikeash 9y agoFrom what I've seen, it virtually always is.
- MaxfordAndSons 9y agoThat's an outrageous statement. The majority of jewish people I know do not support Israel's policies/actions (which, by the way, not supporting its policies/actions does not equate to not supporting its right to exist), and I know many. Are they all anti-semites? I've been to Israel, and many (jewish and not) Israelis I met don't support their nation's policies. So, can confirm, in the real world it sometimes is and sometimes isn't.