2 ms·
I don't buy argument. It confuses economics used to advance political or commercial goals with academic economics. Economics is far ahead other social sciences
by nabla9 9y ago
I don't buy argument. It confuses economics used to advance political or commercial goals with academic economics.
Economics is far ahead other social sciences because it uses mathematical modelling. Models make it easier to see the limits and the scope of the arguments. Ability of outsiders to clearly see oversimplification s is strength.
Rational actor model is the best first order approximation of behaviour. Moving to others, there are others, should be justified carefully.
Other social sciences have it worse.
Btw. Economics is only partially social science. Actors don't have to be humans.
- fiatjaf 9y ago> It confuses economics used to advance political or commercial goals with academic economics. Does it? Or is this totally confused in the practical world too?
- nabla9 9y agoIt's not. For example, the austerity debate has been academically settled. Politicians took one academic paper (outlier) with error and used it to screw things up. IMF did mea culpa after data disagreed.