7 ms·
Cryptoeconomics: Paving the Future of Blockchain Technology
- dreamdu5t 9y agoTerrible article. So many suckers in this mania. 99% of people writing about, trading with, and investing in cryptocurrencies don't know how blockchain or bitcoin even works. It's worse than 1999. The hype and ignorance is astounding.
- deft 9y agoIt's worse but it hasn't reached its peak yet. And I'm sure the peak will be even higher than dotcom.... Kind of fun to watch
- fapjacks 9y agoRight! So get in on the ground floor of this amazing opportunity! /s
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tradersam 9y agoThe same goes for this comment.
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoWhile I tend to agree with this comment, look at the world 17 years after the .com bubble burst. Amazon (founded in 1994) and Google (founded in 1998) absolutely dominate their categories, and the Internet has drastically changed virtually every sector of the economy that it touches. Just like the .com mania, I think there will be a huge fallout when the bubble bursts. But I also think there will be a couple dominant winners to rise from that rubble, and blockchains and cryptocurrencies will have a strong impact in future payment systems.
- criddell 9y agoSo what are the most optimistic projections of where blockchain and cryptocurrency could take us? How about the most pessimistic? Presumably, the likely outcome is somewhere in the middle. What would that look like, say, 20 years from now?
- Torai 9y agoCryptoeconomics: 150% more bs than standard economics and powered by Blockchain Theology.
- pedrocr 9y agoBefore modelling cryptoeconomics maybe someone should apply some sound basic economics to the existing blockchain. Having a cryptocurrency where the founder owns 5% of all the currency that will ever exist and deflation is builtin and fixed seems like it fails some fairly basic things we know about standard economics before we need to start modelling the impacts of cryptoeconomics. Just had an interesting discussion about this on reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/6okg5v/a_hacker_stole_31m_of_etherhow_it_happened_and/dkj8ms4/ https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/6okg5v/a_hacke...
- sillysaurus3 9y agoI mean, it seems to be working. I don't really like the implications either, but it's a bit of a stretch to say it's not economics.
- pedrocr 9y agoI'm not saying it's not economics, just that bitcoin (and the other cryptocurrencies in existence) seem to have quite a few fatal flaws going forward from just our understanding of normal economics, let alone a new branch someone wants to start.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoFrom your Reddit comment: I have no issue with the people that invented a specific technology getting rewarded for that. But that's not what's happening here. You're giving a few early adopters most of what you want to then use to price all the assets in the world. I'm not sure anybody is saying that bitcoin will be used to price all assets in the world. USD currently isn't, for example. It's just the dominant currency. A reasonable estimate for all the dollars in the world is 10 trillion. Say that bitcoin being a full sucess is it being valued at a total of 5 billion. Now consider that Satoshi has about 5% of all bitcoins that will ever exist. That puts him as 3x richer than the current richest man in the world. I don't see anything in bitcoin that justifies that kind of payout and that's for the inventor of the thing. We don't have a justice system. We have a legal system. And this seems to be allowed under our legal system, so I'm not sure the moral argument is valid. Why do you feel it's immoral for Satoshi to own 5%? We don't even know if he's alive or still has access to the coins, but let's say for the sake of argument that he does.
- ftlio 9y agoWhat I think a lot of people will initially miss in the critique of money provided by blockchains (read: Bitcoin) is the topology of the network as helpful in modeling cryptoeconomics (read: economics). Any meaningful definition of a blockchain should prove useful in modeling the systems of money preceded by it. I honestly don't know why people think bitcoins and dollars need separate economics.
- ThomPete 9y agoAgree. All currencies are based on one unifying thing. Trust. There are currencies with far less trust than Bitcoin yet somehow Bitcoin is seen as some alien idea. It's not. It's just a non-fiat currency. It will live and die by the trust of the network.
- ruleabidinguser 9y agoit's also digital, which makes it unique among non fiat currencies.
- KirinDave 9y agoIt really stresses me out how folks have equated PoW algorithms in a chain with a general Byzantine Fault solution. They haven't, and Bitcoin essentially lives and dies by the proposition that it is more valuable to the majority of miners alive than dead. The instant this is not true, there is a potential for a majority of miners to defraud the system and extract value until the value of the currency drops to 0. And of course, the damage to the system just 2-3 colluding miners could do if they wanted is pretty significant, especially if the goal was DoS instead of theft.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- EGreg 9y agoMy main question is: Has anyone found how to solve the double-spend problem WITHOUT global consensus? The original Ripple idea used trustlines. The nice thing about those is that you don't have the double-spend problem. Each entity issues its own currency, so to spea, making it credit-money rather than value-money. I really love the absence of a global ledger recording every transaction ever made - both from a privacy point of view and this one: https://www.scuttlebutt.nz/stories/design-challenge-avoid-centralization-and-singletons.html https://www.scuttlebutt.nz/stories/design-challenge-avoid-ce... But the problem with trustlines is that it's hard for anyone to pay anyone, and the bandwidth of trustlines can be pretty small. Plus, you do have to have the permission of all the intermediaries to make a payment. I would love to have each community issue its own currency without being able to control who pays whom, and without the double spend problem, and without a global ledger of all communities in the world. What are the latest solutioms to this?