3 ms·
This is only tangentially related, but I believe it's time to have a unified login standard for the web. Not in the OAuth sense, as that's hard to do, but just
by StavrosK 9y ago
This is only tangentially related, but I believe it's time to have a unified login standard for the web. Not in the OAuth sense, as that's hard to do, but just a small, machine-readable file that tells your password manager "to log this user in, just submit credentials to /whatever/url/".
That way, your password manager would show a "login" button on the browser's toolbar when you visited any page in a site, you'd click it, and you'd be logged in (or possibly be asked for a two-factor code or be redirected to a two-factor page) immediately and certainly.
Is there anyone here who's working on a password manager who'd like to develop this with me? I've been wanting to write a spec and Django/Python implementation of it.
- jimktrains2 9y ago> just submit credentials to /whatever/url/". No, No. We shouldn't send credentials to anywhere. We should be using things like client certs or SRP. We need to solve the UI and UX problems and actually create better systems, not keep patching over the same broken system.
- StavrosK 9y agoDo you want a marginal improvement that many people might use, or a perfect system that nobody will?
- jimktrains2 9y agoI don't consider something that remember the login URL for a site (which most password managers can store) a marginal improvement at all. Also, "marginal improvement that many people might use, or a perfect system that nobody will?" is a false dichotomy. I'm saying we should make better systems (not perfect ones) easier to use.
- StavrosK 9y ago> I don't consider something that remember the login URL for a site (which most password managers can store) a marginal improvement at all. Me neither, that's why I proposed a system that will allow your password manager to log you in automatically with a single click instead, with a trivial change to the server (a file with some information). > I'm saying we should make better systems (not perfect ones) easier to use. Having seen how little adoption Persona, which was pretty much perfect, got, I don't think the problem is usability.
- eddieroger 9y agoIt's been tried in various flavors of that. The one I liked the best was OpenID. You designate who you trust to actually log you in, which could even be localhost if you set your redirects right, then provide a URL as your "login." There was a somewhat standardized set of data that could go back and forth, and if a specific site needed more, it could ask for it on it's own. The problem, I think, is that every site wants to own the web, and doesn't want to give up anything, let alone login. Facebook and Twitter and Google all want to be the auth providers to the net, but then you have to trust them in a much more elevated way than you should, and their motives are more around building a profile of you and where you go on the net than being a secure auth provider. If Facebook started supporting U2F (they may, I don't know), Yubikey sales would explode tomorrow and the web may be a safer place, who knows.
- StavrosK 9y agoThose are all centralized login systems. I'm talking about just making password managers smarter.