4 ms·
I wonder if you can offer a pair of online dictionary definitions that illustrates what you see as the difference in meaning between the two words. (I bet you c
by justin66 9y ago
I wonder if you can offer a pair of online dictionary definitions that illustrates what you see as the difference in meaning between the two words. (I bet you can't)
- dang 9y agoLook closely enough and you'll see that they all do. One meaning for 'heterodox' is 'holding unorthodox opinions'. That's an attribute of the person, not the opinion. The royal road to clarifying subtle differences in language, however, is etymology, and there the difference is plain. Hetero = different, dox = opinion, ortho = correct. So the distinction here is something like "diverse opinion" vs. "incorrect opinion", which to me seems clearly meaningful.
- justin66 9y agoCool.
- pvg 9y agoThe royal road to clarifying subtle differences in language, however, is etymology, and there the difference is plain. Is it? (to either of those things). In current English usage, 'unorthodox' doesn't mean 'incorrect' and doesn't connote 'incorrect'.
- DonHopkins 9y agoEtymology be damned: I'm still trying to figure out if he meant "royal" as in "Royale with Cheese" or "royal" as in "royal pain in the ass".
- dragonwriter 9y ago> The royal road to clarifying subtle differences in language, however, is etymology No, it's not. Etymology tells you where a word came from, not what it means (either in denotation or connotation) in current usage. It will often be completely misleading in trying to unpack subtle differences in meaning.
- dang 9y agoI couldn't disagree more.
- DonHopkins 9y agoHow is heterodoxophobia more nuanced than literally meaning being afraid of different opinions? http://tcpc.blogs.com/musings/2010/05/homodoxuals-and-heterodoxuals-in-the-church.html http://tcpc.blogs.com/musings/2010/05/homodoxuals-and-hetero...
- jhpriestley 9y agoThere is definitely a difference in meaning, maybe just in specialized fields like theology and economics. An Austrian school economist, or an Arianist in the early Christian church, would be called "heterodox" but probably not "unorthodox". It has the connotation of following a definite tradition that is not the main tradition in the field. "Unorthodox" means something more like "doing your own thing", so Steven Levitt (the Freakonomics guy) might be called an "unorthodox economist" because he studies unusual topics like drug dealers, but not a "heterodox economist" because he studies these strange topics using mainstream theories. I think "heterodox" fits reasonably well in this article, it suggests that these engineers are following a distinct tradition, not just "doing their own thing".
- telharmonium 9y agoFunnily enough, an essay cited by the article contains this quote in its opening paragraph: "...defining a heterogeneous orthodoxy for the coming Information Age..." [1] Presumably Victor's research group is working in opposition to this conventional thinking, making them... unheterorthodox? 1. 'THE CALIFORNIAN IDEOLOGY' - http://www.imaginaryfutures.net/2007/04/17/the-californian-ideology-2/ http://www.imaginaryfutures.net/2007/04/17/the-californian-i...