6 ms·
Are There More Girl Geniuses?
- jeb 16y agoThe article seems neutral till the last lines: The developing gender gap in the gifted programs of New York City does not signal that girls are smarter than boys. Rather, it exemplifies how well-intentioned government officials and educators can disregard boys’ needs and abilities and unwittingly adopt policies detrimental to boys’ well-being. It is a small part of the long story of how American boys across the ability spectrum and in all age groups have become second-class citizens in the nation’s schools.
- alayne 16y agoZing. I remember reading/watching studies of classroom settings a few years ago where teachers were unconsciously giving boys a better learning experience. It was eye opening. I thought there was a fairly established result in gender bias studies of education -- boys get more opportunities, more teacher interaction, and the system encourages them more. Maybe this is more fair?
- jerf 16y agoWhen was that, exactly? Things have changed, from top to bottom. Everything seems to be totally restructured for girls. The much-better-examined question is why females are getting more bachelor's degrees then males in college, by a percentage that if it were any other group would be prima facie proof of widespread discrimination. http://iserp.columbia.edu/news/articles/female-advantage-college http://iserp.columbia.edu/news/articles/female-advantage-col... says 2004 saw 58% female graduation, and the disparity's trend is up, not down. We need to wipe out the idea that education is somehow biased towards males now, and fast. The playing field has gone from balanced to stacked in favor of females and it's still being tipped yet further in that direction. ("Why does it matter?" It is, as the article says, fairly well established that variance in male intelligence is larger than female intelligence. It is also fairly well established that progress is made in society in a very unbalanced manner, where most progress is made by the outliers in skill. Throwing away the males because the education system labels the usual male child learning styles pathological because they can't be properly corralled is not the path to a society able to compete on the global stage.)
- kenjackson 16y agoAs a male, and father of males, I can honestly say that if any male feels like they are being systematically being discriminated against in school, they need to "man up". Even if there is some gender bias in schools, everything else in society is so male-centric that the scale still way tips toward male.
- Groxx 16y agoEverything else? How about child-rearing / anything to do with children? Males are pretty often feared as being pedophiles if they work with kids.
- kenjackson 16y agoFair. There are some places where men have a tougher time. Daycare provider is one. Figure skating and porn star are probably some others. But all up, it's still not even close.
- Groxx 16y agohttp://www.eeoc.gov/eeoc/statistics/employment/jobpat-eeo1/2008/us/national.html http://www.eeoc.gov/eeoc/statistics/employment/jobpat-eeo1/2... With a couple significant outliers (most in men's favor, but not all), it's actually pretty close. Though I'm not sure what "professionals" relates to.
- kenjackson 16y agoIt's really not very close. The "outliers" are things like "execute" where men dominate more than 2:1. The only places where women have more of are clerical and sales positions. And really the real question, if you're interested in workforce data is money. There's a huge gap between men and women: http://usgovinfo.about.com/od/censusandstatistics/a/paygapgrows.htm http://usgovinfo.about.com/od/censusandstatistics/a/paygapgr... Now of course the standard reply is "they work different jobs". And that's true. Jobs men work tend to pay more. Why is that? Who knows. And if you look at the historic pay of fields like psychology, once dominated by men, it used to pay very well. As women began to play a large role in the field, pay dropped. Did men leave because pay drop or did pay drop because men left? No one knows. But I still believe my fundamental point. If you're a man and you're not doing as well as you like and it's because you think women have done you in, I just personally have a low opinion of you. Not that you'd care about my opinion, but that's just my take. And I'll raise my kids, to the best of my ability, to not believe that they can't get a fair shot in life because women run the show.
- mctavjb9 16y agoUnlike Switzerland, the American Enterprise Institute isn't exactly known for being a bastion of neutrality. The author's other cause celebre is that people should stop whining about women being underrepresented in math and the hard sciences. Her AEI profile (http://www.aei.org/scholar/56 http://www.aei.org/scholar/56) informs us that she is "preparing to write a book on the lost history of conservative feminism." As a non-white, non-male physics PhD, I can't wait to read that one.
- strebler 16y ago"The greater variance of males on intelligence tests is one of the best-established findings in psychometric literature" And this is supported by a graph from 1932? I'm not saying it isn't true, but surely there is more recent data to support one of the "best-established findings" of that field.
- trunnell 16y agoThe data are from 1932 but the analysis is more recent: here is what a group of Scottish psychologists found in 2002 when they analyzed the results of IQ tests given to nearly all 11-year-olds in Scotland in 1932
- tkahn6 16y agoAccording to the graph in the middle of the article (unless I'm reading it wrong) it would seem that there are more male geniuses. The graph then, would seem to indicate that the sort of tests that determine a child's eligibility for entrance into the gifted programs in New York either a) do not track with IQ tests or b) filter out children with IQs lower than say 95 (therefore making more girls eligible than boys).
- strebler 16y agoI had the same initial reaction to the graph, but she seems to be using the graph to show that reality may be at odds with the enrollment numbers. Data from 1932 does seem quite out of place in an article addressing "recent trends". She goes on to suggest that the gifted programs are more targeted to girls - things like verbal-oriented tests and needing to "sit still" for periods of time.
- tkahn6 16y agoYeah. It would be interesting to know if intelligence distributions remain constant from generation to generation.
- Daniel_Newby 16y agoThe 1932 data described in the article is important because it covered nearly the entire population of a country for a particular age group -- uneven data collection could not have skewed the results. Uneven data collection is the great enemy of psychological public policy, since politicians can so conveniently project their dispute onto the people that were not sampled. The 1932 Scotland data slams that door shut. Other testing programs since then have showed a slow, steady rise in the average IQ, called the Flynn effect. However the relative shapes of the male and female histograms have been quite constant. (Ditto for the relative shapes of the racial curves.)
- tokenadult 16y agoDitto for the relative shapes of the racial curves. There has been some convergence, that is lessening of a gap, among race and ethnicity groups in the United States as a matter of group averages.
- frossie 16y agoI hate the title because it is linkbait for the obvious conclusion, which it does reach: Pre-school and school performance is so dominated by non-sheer-smarts characteristics (such as the ability to concentrate on a long test at an early age) that trying to derive any meaningful conclusion about gender/race/size-of-your-nose outlier intelligence patterns is almost moot. Not only are most people not geniuses, but most successful people are not geniuses either. What's with the obsession already?
- angstrom 16y agoThe obsession people have with 'genius' is due to a misguided understanding of what genius is and an assumption that it somehow makes life significantly easier. It's the same obsession people have with the lottery and believing it will solve all their ills. Smarts and money are both capital; through hard work you can get more.
- rada 16y agoI hate ad hominem arguments but in this case I feel I must. The author, although a woman herself, has a clearly defined agenda that smacks of misogynism. Here is a telling quote from her interview with the Esquire Magazine: There are a lot of homely women in women's studies. Preaching these anti-male, anti-sex sermons is a way for them to compensate for various heartaches - they're just mad at the beautiful girls. Every one of her articles is based on exact same formula: women claim they are disadvantaged, men are disadvantaged. ARE THERE MORE GIRL GENIUSES? American boys have become second-class citizens in the nation's schools. THE EQUAL PAY DAY REALITY CHECK The claim that American women face wage discrimination is groundless. BASELESS BIAS AND THE NEW SECOND SEX Claims of bias against women in academic science are exaggerated; meanwhile men are becoming the second sex in American higher education. WHY CAN'T A WOMAN BE MORE LIKE A MAN? Evidence of gender bias in math and science is flimsy at best. I wouldn't rely on her musings for intelligent insight. The studies she presents are cherry-picked and her arguments are so one-sided and cliched it barely qualifies as an opinion piece. The recent article in the Atlantic (http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2010/07/the-end-of-men/8135/ http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2010/07/the-end-...) was much more balanced and insightful.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI don't even understand the point of your ad-hominem. The author is being formulaic. So what? She is a one-issue writer, and therefore her opinions are incorrect?
- rada 16y agoOk, let's say someone had written an opinion piece on how Windows is unfairly portrayed compared to Linux. You read it, and it just seems, I don't know, off. Perhaps it's the fact that they illustrated their point with a feature comparison graph dated to 1991 (a fair comparison to the author's use of 1932 data), or maybe it just reads as a long-winded rant as opposed to an intelligent inquiry into the subject of operating systems. You look into it a bit, and it turns out that the author was once quoted as saying that Linus Torvalds is just a loser, jealous of Bill Gates's wealth. You look at their other articles, and see that every one is the same old template: yay Windows, nay Linux, yay numbers that support my opinion, nay numbers that do not. What would you conclude, if not that the author is, indeed, incorrect? I don't have a problem with a "one-issue" writer but I do have a problem with a evidence-be-damned "one-sided" writer.
- Groxx 16y agoWell, there's this one at least: http://www.girlgeniusonline.com/ http://www.girlgeniusonline.com/
- amalcon 16y agoWhat about relative application numbers? These things are partially self-selected. The first thing that occurred to me when I read the main observations in the article* was, "What if the proportion of girls in the programs is higher because more girls (or parents of girls) want to participate in the programs?" Wanting to participate (and especially having parents who want one to participate) would not necessarily be correlated with intelligence anyway. *- That 1) gifted and talented programs in New York are tending to have more female students, and 2) this cannot be explained by suggesting that there are more gifted and talented girls.
- tokenadult 16y agoWhat about relative application numbers? That's a very good question. I think the study of application to graduate departments at the University of California: Berkeley (often used in statistics textbooks as an example of Simpson's paradox) showed that what initially appeared as a bias in favor of male applicants was actually, when analyzed department by department, neutral admission or bias in favor of female applicants. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson%27s_paradox#Berkeley_sex_bias_case http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson%27s_paradox#Berkeley_se... The self-selection involved in applying or not for a special program is surely relevant to analyzing bias, as you correctly point out. A different issue that other commenters here mention is whether participation in a school program at early elementary age has any necessary relation to adult career paths at later ages.