6 ms·
Punish organizations spreading fake bullshit. Facebook makes a lot of money on the parade of bullshit that they enable and propagate. Sanction them, tie them u
by Spooky23 9y ago
Punish organizations spreading fake bullshit.
Facebook makes a lot of money on the parade of bullshit that they enable and propagate. Sanction them, tie them up in investigations and fines and magically they'll find a way to stop propaganda.
Alex Jones is a snake oil salesman. Aggressively pursue his financial dealings and poof, he goes away.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- notahacker 9y agoThe implications of this idea look a little less attractive when one considers who has the power to impose fines on people and corporations for publishing news they don't agree is true...
- Consultant32452 9y agoThis is the best thing about Donald Trump being the President. Perhaps the only good thing. "We should fine people for saying untrue things." "You think it's a good idea to let Donald Trump determine what is true and levy fines against anyone he disagrees with?" I'm trying to turn this into a "thing." If you wouldn't let Donald Trump manage your 401k, maybe we shouldn't give our retirement funds (SS) to the government. How about your health insurance? Want him running that? etc.
- colemannugent 9y agoThis is a great way to communicate these ideas to people who would otherwise be hostile to them. I think you're right about this being the best thing about his presidency. Let's make this a thing.
- anigbrowl 9y agoIt won't become A Thing since Trump's administration is an objectively abrupt departure from the mean. It's irrational to argue that democratically elected government (in the general sense, not the US instance in particular) is fundamentally less reliable than the private sector where accountability and influence are more narrowly distributed.
- Consultant32452 9y agoDon't worry, maybe not the next term, but a Republican will win the Presidency again, and then we can switch to that name. Replace Donald Trump with Paul Ryan, or Mike Pence, or Newt Gingrich, or Sara Palin. The repulsion will be the same.
- Sangermaine 9y agoA dishonest libertarian, what a surprise. Everyone, even Republicans, agrees that Trump is an anomaly. Liberals didn't like Romney, for example, but they didn't believe he was simply incompetent and incapable of basic governance in the way they do Trump. It's an almost childish view of the world to think that the fact that sometimes your side doesn't win means people should or will abandon faith in the ability of government to provide services. The very point of democracy is that you accept that sometimes you're not going to win.
- Consultant32452 9y agoI absolutely LOVE that you've defined "win" here as associating with the person you as an individual desire to associate with. I wonder if we could devise some sort of mechanism by which each individual person could be free to choose this on their own, then everyone could win.
- bsder 9y ago> If you wouldn't let Donald Trump manage your 401k, maybe we shouldn't give our retirement funds (SS) to the government. How about your health insurance? Want him running that? etc. Your analogy is poor: I wouldn't want Trump running the fire department, but I want that as a government function. We know what privatizing a fire department does. Trump is a symptom, not the cause. The cause is a set of people willing to swallow propaganda and fear, uncritically.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Consultant32452 9y ago>I wouldn't want Trump running the fire department, but I want that as a government function. This is not an either or proposition. >We know what privatizing a fire department does. Half of Denmark's population is served by private fire departments. What has it done, exactly? For the record, I'm not opposed to public fire departments, but this illustrates the benefit of pushing the power of government as locally as possible. Let's consider the 'face punch' theory of political discourse. If your county commissioner is really fucking things up, there's a fair chance you'll eventually run across them at the local coffee shop and you can punch them in the face. Maybe you wind up in jail for a few days, but enough face punches and things will start to change. If you try that on the President, you'll probably be killed before you ever lay a finger on him. Now, I'm not actually advocating violence here, just illustrating the differential of influence in a hopefully comical way.
- chc 9y agoThis could just as well argue against the government doing anything at all — policing, running a military, prosecuting fraudsters, running the post office — and yet most people view those institutions as at least a conditional good and would not be happier if the government never did these things. Similarly, if my wife were a murderer, she could easily kill me in my sleep, but this doesn't mean I'm against the general idea of sharing a bedroom with my wife — it just means that marrying a crazy person is bad.
- Consultant32452 9y agoIt's certainly an argument to minimize the scope of government to as small as possible. >Similarly, if my wife were a murderer, she could easily kill me in my sleep, but this doesn't mean I'm against the general idea of sharing a bedroom with my wife — it just means that marrying a crazy person is bad. This is a perfect analogy because you are 100% in control of who you choose as your wife. You may make a bad choice, but you choosing a bad wife doesn't kill everyone. It just kills you. Meanwhile, less than 1/5 of us chose Trump and now he is managing your healthcare, your retirement, and your military.
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> you are 100% in control of who you choose as your wife Don't I wish. You're 100% in control of who you don't choose as your wife; you have substantially less control over who you do choose.
- wwweston 9y ago> If you wouldn't let Donald Trump manage your 401k, maybe we shouldn't give our retirement funds (SS) to the government. Yes, obviously we should keep all retirement funds in the private sector, where clearly no one like Donald Trump would ever be in a position of authority.
- anth1988 9y agoDon't worry, if you pray hard the free market will take care of you.
- deltr0n 9y agothe point is that you've got choices in the private sector. if you don't want the private sector version of donald trump managing your money, then choose someone else.
- wwweston 9y agoThat's certainly a point among a number of others one could make, but it wasn't the point of the GP, which was that the risks involved with having the government manage anything are reasonably characterized by a Trump presidency. If Trump serves as a cautionary example of potential governance issues in the public sector, he serves better as a cautionary example of potential management issues in the private sector, given his long career there. There are better ones, of course. If we're picking tail events like Trump, one might just as well say the risks of having the private sector manage retirement funds are accurately characterized by the various market failures surrounding the 2008 crash (which were, however private, hard to avoid the effects of even with a surfeit of personal choice). On top of that, since you wanted to talk about personal choice... of course there's choice and accountability in public institutions, it just works differently: you have to select management cooperatively, and the collective decision might be different than your choice. That really has a fair bit in common with a number of private sector retirement vehicles (which are likely enough selected by your private employer), but there are others which are more individual and it's nice to be able to take your ball and go elsewhere. But even there, you don't necessarily get a clear signal when someone whose competence is as limited or anyone whose incentives are as misaligned with yours as Trump's are gets involved with your retirement fund's management. In fact, I'd go so far as to say in most cases you'd have less scrutiny and fewer journalistic resources to turn to in order to make that assessment than you would in the typical selection process for public office. Now what you often would have are claimed/recorded rates of return. But since we're thinking about that question, maybe we should talk about how a typical 401k compares to returns for Social Security: http://www.jameswrussell.com/?p=81 http://www.jameswrussell.com/?p=81
- 09bjb 9y ago"Hacker News is fake. It's all fake. I asked to shut it down. Wonderful!" /s
- CM30 9y agoYep, and that's also something a lot of people tend not to consider when talking about free speech and censorship. What happens when the 'other side' takes power? Or if an actual tyrant takes control of the government? Suddenly the idea of punishing people for wrongspeak/think becomes a hell of a lot less attractive.
- Spooky23 9y agoThe civil service is resilient and effective.
- Consultant32452 9y ago>Alex Jones is a snake oil salesman. Aggressively pursue his financial dealings and poof, he goes away. I think that would be counterproductive. It would have the affect of "proving" he's right because people are coming after him. Also, consider that Infowars has the same number of subscribers on Youtube as CNN. Now, Youtube subscribers is a crude tool for measuring social value, but apparently world that consists of Youtube watchers has determined that Infowars is on par with CNN with regards to social value.
- CM30 9y agoThis is another good point. A lot of people with... somewhat strange views (especially conspiracy theorists) are already super paranoid that the government is trying to shut them up. Try and punish them for 'lying', and well you just strengthern their cause for the people who follow them. Turn them into a sort of martyr for their followers. Probably not a good idea in a world where "the elite want to shut down criticism to bring back a one world order" is something people actually believe in some circles.
- weberc2 9y agoI don't think I want the government to have the authority to decide what is and isn't true and to police the internet accordingly. I like free speech, even when much of it is crap.
- chc 9y agoThere are lots of cases where lying is a crime, and I think most people agree that this is as it should be. So I feel like "I don't want the government to have the authority to decide what is and isn't true" can't possibly be the right reason, because the government already does that and it's not even controversial. For example: Do you feel the same way about, say, drug advertising? Can I tell people my mercury tablets are actually basil and that they cure cancer? What about pretending to be a police officer? What about soliciting investments with false guarantees? I don't think most people feel that these things need to be legal. So it seems more like a nuanced question of where to draw lines than a clear-cut "the government must not be able to punish lying."
- weberc2 9y agoSure. There's a gradient of risk and we make exceptions for things which are very likely to cause significant harm. Should we do away with the rule because it needs exceptions? No.
- skolos 9y agoUnfortunately this sounds similar to how Putin dealt with free media in Russia. In the end what was not killed was mostly taken over by government. There is a reason first amendment protects all speech.
- Danihan 9y ago>Punish Punishments enacted by whom? You want the government to punish free speech?
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> Facebook makes a lot of money on the parade of bullshit that they enable and propagate. How about punishing people publishing fake bullshit? Facebook is about as responsible here as e.g. Hacker News, except here the audience is a bit more able to detect lies in articles. But all the bullshit you see on Facebook is created neither by FB, nor by its users. The bullshit is created by news websites and magazines. How about punishing journalists and editors for a change?
- jdavis703 9y agoWho is spreading "fake bullshit" though? Both sides say the other is fake. The idea is no one now knows what is real or fake, or indeed no one even cares about what's real or fake. The idea is to make what is fake or real irrelevant so that those who control the levers of power can continue doing so. Information is no longer power, information is a threat.
- thephyber 9y ago> Information is no longer power, information is a threat. Information is still power, you have just pointed out that information dissemination is much more democratized than it has been in the past. Those who choose to peddle snake oil or completely fabricated news have always had a platform ("yellow news" of the Hearst publication hayday), it used to be guarded by very few gatekeepers. Now, the internet is rife with blogs posing as news corps, "satire" sites that don't bother to try to be funny, social media full of what used to be chain letters, and {AM radio, podcasts, YouTube videos} of fringe conspiracy theorists. These people always had a channel for their information, only those fringe channels weren't widely subscribed. Now, InfoWars / Alex Jones and ABC News have the same footprint on social media, making lesser informed information consumers think they are equally acceptable options.
- ajross 9y ago> Sanction them, tie them up in investigations and fines [...] Aggressively pursue his financial dealings What's the mechanism you propose to ensure these tools are only used against snake oil salesmen? Would you hand that metaphorically loaded gun to our current president?