3 ms·
It's quite possible for more than 50% of people to be above average drivers. If there are 100 people, and 80 of them cause no accidents, and the other 20 cause
by rmc 16y ago
It's quite possible for more than 50% of people to be above average drivers. If there are 100 people, and 80 of them cause no accidents, and the other 20 cause 10 accidents each, then there are 2 accidents per driver. 80% have less than average accident rate. By the same logic it's possible for most people to have a below average salary. Once extremes are possible, then averages start being less applicable.
However for things that have no extrmeme (e.g. height, IQs), the above average and below average rates are similar.,
- blaix 16y agoI think the percents are merely anecdotal and the main point is to keep an open mind. Don't assume you are always right.
- paulgb 16y agoGood point, but if you follow through to the source of the driving statistic that Derek quoted, they're actually using the median rather than the mean. Also, you've defined the "goodness" of drivers as a discrete measure. If you defined it as a continuous measure (say, a function of risky behavior and fuel consumption), then it is impossible by definition for more than 50% of drivers to be above average. (I'm guilty of self-plagiarism here http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=191101 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=191101)
- thaumaturgy 16y agoYes, you're exactly right. The quote that drives this home for me is, "Most people have an above average number of legs."
- Avshalom 16y agoIf you take the Mean. Hence the ideas of median and mode, both of which in this case would cough up 0 accidents as the "average." Importantly the majority of things talking about "percentile" are using a median for "average"