4 ms·
> One of the reasons why the Renault Kwid is $4000 is because, well, it uses cheap materials, and with that comes a very bad safety rating. Still, better safet
by mschuster91 9y ago
> One of the reasons why the Renault Kwid is $4000 is because, well, it uses cheap materials, and with that comes a very bad safety rating.
Still, better safety rating than a scooter, and that's the most important part (next to way better emission control, as scooters generally use nasty 2-stroke engines).
- smcg 9y agoA valid point. I honestly don't know what is best for India, but the Kwid is a step forward in innovation, at least. It would have been nice if the article covered these points, like some of the others I've read on the Kwid.
- weeksie 9y agoBetter safety for the driver of the car, not the poor bastard on a scooter that gets mowed down ;)
- mschuster91 9y agoIf you're on a scooter you get mowed down regardless if the colliding party is a scooter, a car or a truck. And even if the colliding party is a scooter, there's still all the traffic behind it. So it doesn't matter. That is a job for the government to actually hire and train cops to enforce traffic rules (red lights, DUI, right-of-way)...
- gorkonsine 9y agoCars are generally faster than scooters. If everyone else is driving a scooter too, you're much less likely to get hurt in a crash, or to have a crash, because the energies are much lower and the speeds are much lower (low speeds make it easier to avoid crashes). Also, momentum is a real thing. Getting hit by a scooter at 10mph isn't nearly as bad as getting hit by a truck at 10mph.
- chrisseaton 9y ago> Still, better safety rating than a scooter Is it? I mean maybe it is, I don't know, but I'm guessing you don't really know either. I can imagine that maybe a scooter could be safer than a very bad car. You can get crushed in a car, cars go faster, you've got less situational awareness. I'm not sure this is one of those things that is just obviously true.
- mschuster91 9y agoA car at least can handle potholes etc. while an overlooked pothole, oil spill etc will bring you to fall (and likely injury) on a scooter. Situational awareness is a thing, though - especially in extremely crowded traffic.
- Shorel 9y agoI drive both, and any car is much safer than the scooter. But the scooter beats traffic jams.
- alasdair_ 9y agoA car is much safer to the DRIVER but it's likely less safe to everyone else on the road.
- Shorel 9y agoNot necessarily true. In my experience, motorcycle riders are much less attentive to blinkers and take a lot more risks on the road. This affects all drivers. However, AFAIK, in most of the USA (that's it, not in California) motorcycle riding is a lot more strict, with regard to lane-splitting. Only where lane-splitting is banned I can agree with your point. In most of the world, where lane-splitting is the norm, my point stands.
- lclarkmichalek 9y agoSafety ratings do not account for different speeds, and different driving styles, so it's probably best to assume those are equal, for the sake of the conversion (which is about _safety rating_). Cars are slow to crush. If you're involved in a collision while on a scooter, you don't have a crumple zone to slow down whatever might be eventually hitting you. Cars have seatbelts. If you're hit on a scooter, you are more likely to be thrown out of the vehicle, compared to being hit while in a car. Being thrown out of a vehicle is not good for your survival rate. I actually have no clue what safety features scooters have, if any. Cars have a ton.
- barrkel 9y agoCan you name a 2-stroke model scooter being sold new in India? Everything I can find currently being sold is 4-stroke. In fact AFAICT 2-strokes are illegal to sell new in India. (Personally I'd rather ride a scooter than drive a tiny car in a dense urban area, because my awareness is much higher on a scooter, and also I've ridden scooters around London for a decade.)
- mschuster91 9y agoTIL. My level of knowledge apparently is at 2014 (e.g. http://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/twostroke-vehicles-are-the-worst-polluters-44402 http://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/twostroke-vehicles-are-th...). The problem is, even if no new ones are sold, there will be a mass of old 2-stroke scooters being used/sold until they break...
- lmm 9y agoSure, but comparing a newly-released car to 3+-year-old scooters seems likely to be misleading.
- kamaal 9y agoAs an India staying in Bangalore, this is spot on. There is one more important thing its urban parking spaces. You can never build enough car parking for India's urban population density. This is apart from the fact that scooters give better mileage(Motorcycles even better). My Bajaj discover 150cc gives 60-70 kilometers/litre.