4 ms·
If I'm not too indiscreet, mind if I ask how much did the whole treatment cost?
by elorant 9y ago
If I'm not too indiscreet, mind if I ask how much did the whole treatment cost?
- byteCoder 9y agoSince this was conducted under a research trial by the US government, the treatment did not cost me (or my health insurance) a penny. I am told that the treatment and follow-ups cost the research program budget at least a million dollars per patient.
- slantedview 9y agoAn important example of the government's role in medicine.
- credit_guy 9y agoThis is a mind blowing amount. What could be the reason for such a high cost?
- wyager 9y agoCutting edge scientific research is expensive. I don't know why people expect advanced medicine to be cheap. Synthesizing or extracting complex proteins, using rare medical radioisotopes, medical scanners based on the most cutting edge engineering and physics... Almost no endeavor besides physics and medicine makes regular use of superconductors, antimatter (for PET scans), etc.
- credit_guy 9y ago> I don't know why people expect advanced medicine to be cheap Nobody said cheap. People (me included) actually expect immunotherapy to be expensive. A course of Perjeta/Herceptin can go to $188k (per [1]). But many are already outraged by this number. A course of Rituxan can be about $14k to the patient, and you could say it's dirt cheap compared to Herceptin, but it appears the cost to the manufacturer is $300 ([2]). As for superconductors, antimatter, and all other sci-fi sounding things, the cost of an PET scan is about $7k, and of an MRI scan is less than half that, so that can't explain the million we're talking about here. I think we simply became insensitive to hearing big numbers in the context of healthcare. The birth of my second son cost my insurance about $130k (they covered 90%, but I still had to fork out about $15k), and he didn't have any surgery, or anything major. So yes, I can understand $1MM for cancer treatment, but allow me to be mindblown all the same. I don't think $130k was reasonable for a delivery, and I don't think $1MM is reasonable for immunotherapy (which again, does not involve surgery). [1] http://www.fiercepharma.com/regulatory/fda-approves-roche-s-pricey-new-herceptin-partner-perjeta http://www.fiercepharma.com/regulatory/fda-approves-roche-s-... [2] http://consumersunion.org/outrageous-health-costs/cancer-drug-markup/ http://consumersunion.org/outrageous-health-costs/cancer-dru...
- pm90 9y agoI'm going to assume the lion's share of costs in something as routine as a regular delivery of a baby (i.e. no complications) is probably going to be: Hospital expenses and doctor/surgery costs. IMO paying thousands of dollars to surgeons is definitely justified. I have several doctors in the extended fam, some of whom are surgeons. One of my cousins is studying to be one. Its just fucking crazy how much effort is required to be a doctor (not to mention all the costs assosciated with the education itself). So personally, I think the labor costs of surgery are justified. The hospital charges make sense too as you're under supervision by trained nurses and living in a room built with specialized equipment. I had an appendectomy recently. Everything included (surgery, hospital charges, drugs etc.) came to ~ $55k. Insurance paid most of it and I was ultimately charged around $5k. With that in mind $130k doesn't sound unreasonable for a delivery of a baby.
- ChrisRR 9y agoEven only taking salaries into account, you've got the surgeons and all associated staff in the removal of the tumour. The guys in the lab to cultivate the white blood cells, everyone who needs to fill out paperwork, more surgery, monitoring and check ups. Then add into that all the costs of running a hospital, proprietary medication, regulatory compliance, cost of all the single disposables. The costs very quickly add up to a few hundred thousand before anyone's even taken a profit.
- jbb67 9y agoI presume the incremental cost of treating each additional patient will be considerably smaller once the overheads of treating the first person are made.
- URSpider94 9y agoNot necessarily. Even in regular use, this treatment will still involve killing off the patient's immune system, which will require days in hospital isolation. In addition, the culturing and screening of the immune cells to create a population that is primed to fight cancer is a labor-intensive process that has to be done for every patient.
- mullen 9y agoI thought trials are free. This is prevent "snake oil salesmen" from trying to sell cures that are not.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]