3 ms·
With this paragraph alone, he has doomed his project to failure: "Right now, Hoff sells the boxes for $275 for 10, manufactured in his native Holland, but he e
by ars 16y ago
With this paragraph alone, he has doomed his project to failure:
"Right now, Hoff sells the boxes for $275 for 10, manufactured in his native Holland, but he envisions local production wherever the box is sold. "I think it's a disaster that the only people who know how to weave clothing are in China," he said. Gardening and home-improvement stores could sell them for about $15, he said."
The problem is that local production costs more. If it costs more it will be used less. It's as simple as that.
He should pick his battles. Conserving water, and growing trees is awesome. Let others worry about China, focus on your mission.
My prediction: Unless he gives up this ideal you will never hear about these boxes again.
- sdfx 16y agoYes. Just think about how much more of these boxes he could sell if he produces them dirt cheap in China. This could easily offset all the negative impacts of shipping etc. He even says himself that if you plant enough trees, an increase in CO2 emissions can be offset. Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good.
- sethg 16y agoIf he’s not interested in patenting the box and enforcing the patent worldwide, then Chinese manufacturers are free to make the box and sell it (or the Chinese government can give the boxes away as part of its own foreign-aid programs), whether Hoff thinks that’s a good idea or not. Also, if it’s possible to design a variant of the box that farmers or unemployed workers can build for themselves out of locally available materials, then the locally built product may be competitive with the imported version.
- thwarted 16y agoThe last slide on http://www.groasis.com/page/uk/principle.php http://www.groasis.com/page/uk/principle.php seems particularly odd in an idealistic sense: With the waterboxx we can transform most of the deserts into forests Deserts are an obvious harsh climate, to humans who live in, uh, more temperate zones in urban areas, but they are not completely barren to the point they need to be "saved". All one needs to do is watch the popular Planet Earth series to see that. Reforestation should be concentrated on in those areas that are having trouble recovering after we've explicitly removed all the trees, not areas that never had trees to begin with.