3 ms·
The point is we don't necessarily know, or know to the degree of certainty the FDA requires, how many of these things degrade. Perhaps in certain conditions, t
by kbenson 9y ago
The point is we don't necessarily know, or know to the degree of certainty the FDA requires, how many of these things degrade. Perhaps in certain conditions, they degrade at one rate, but in other conditions (such as a temperature difference), they degrade at a different rate. Testing how drugs perform years after production in multiple different scenarios is necessarily time consuming, because it takes at least that much time to be sure.
- perseusprime11 9y agoI see medicines in foreign countries wrapped in some kind of aluminum foil. Will that prolong the life of the medicine given there is no oxygen to react? Given the amount of money spent on medicines, I really think there is a good moral business case to identify the correct expiration dates and save money for people. We just went through the Health care ordeal. Money saved anywhere is money saved for people who desperately need healthcare to work for them.
- paublyrne 9y agoThere may be other ways to approach this from a moral point of view. High prices for medicines are defended on the basis of high research costs, not high manufacture costs. A case could be made for legislation that obliges free replacement of out of date medication for the original purchaser, perhaps with a small surcharge.
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoA case could be made for smaller packages so people are less likely to take out of date medications as well.
- Allyssa99 9y agolike Shawn responded I didn't know that someone able to make $6367 in one month on the > internet . read more>>>>>>>>>>>https://tinyurl.com/ly6hd5g https://tinyurl.com/ly6hd5g
- tripzilch 9y agoExcept the medicines themselves aren't expensive. The prices are that high because the pharma companies demand it, because of all the tests, which are their main source of income. That is why prices in the US are so much higher than elsewhere (because of the political power of lobbying and cultural acceptance of price screwing the public on medical things). Given that it's the very same party that would be doing the testing for expiration dates, I kind of doubt they would research this out of the goodness of their corporate hearts. Effectively the same outcome could be realised without the effort of extra testing anything: by just lowering the price of medicine a bit; big pharma would make less money, the public would have more medicine for cheaper.
- mechnesium 9y agoI'm a test engineer. Highly accelerated life testing (HALT) can probably be used to closely approximate the shelf life of medicine. You need to look at the parameters that cause degradation (humidity, temperature, light exposure, etc). HALT the samples at different temperature/humidity/lighting extremes and use mass spectrometry to check purity. Use the data to create an algorithm that approximates the product lifetime and then correlate the results with actual shelf life for verification.
- traek 9y agoA good model really isn't good enough in medicine. Real data from clinical trials is needed, and nobody has an incentive to fund that.
- seehafer 9y agoUnfortunately, ALT is not a solution, because it's not accepted by FDA, except as a temporary measure. Any drug submission that supports shelf life via ALT data will be expected to also say "and we're doing real time testing to support this", and FDA will expect the follow up real-time data.
- GordonS 9y agoThen perhaps the solution is for the FDA to allow HALT testing. Having said that, I imagine there is little incentive for pharma companies to willingly extend the shelf life of their products - perhaps the real solution is for the FDA to actually require HALT testing.
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoI think the real thing here is, "Better safe than sorry". It's fine to use things like HALT testing initially to say, "this drug should be effective for 8 years" so that folks can get it to market before 8 years have passed. But if, in reality, that drug only lasts for a strong 5 years, after which time it loses effectiveness, especially in high humidity or with high UV exposure. We could catch this with real-time tests and adjust accordingly - before it actually affects the general public's health.