9 ms·
> The claim was that Twilio was "mostly anonymous", which isn't true. If you accept that anonymity isn't a purely true/false proposition, which you are doing b
by justin66 9y ago
> The claim was that Twilio was "mostly anonymous", which isn't true.
If you accept that anonymity isn't a purely true/false proposition, which you are doing by using the word "mostly," having your identity only available to law enforcement after a court order has been issued seems like a textbook instance of "mostly anonymous."
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dahauns 9y ago>having your identity only available to law enforcement after a court order or after a security breach...or after access by a third party without a court order (however unlawful it might be)...
- emodendroket 9y agoAren't we comparing this to a cell phone and service I could buy from CVS with cash and no ID?
- justin66 9y agoPossibly? In this sort of continuum of anonymity we're talking about, that's probably a lot more anonymous (but it isn't fully anonymous unless you're paying someone else to buy the phone for you in a different city, and they don't know who you are, and probably some other things I'm not paranoid enough to think of). It's still fine to say Twilio is "mostly anonymous," and objecting to that - that Twilio is "mostly anonymous" - on the basis that law enforcement can find out who you are with a court order is very silly. As if a service that requires due process of law to uncover any information about you is morally or practically equivalent to having your name and address in the white pages.
- emodendroket 9y agoIt's not any more anonymous than any other cell phone if "anonymous" simply means it's not listed anywhere.
- justin66 9y agoSo should we just say it's not anonymous at all? Eliminate the whole notion of "mostly anonymous?" That's what the argument was. If Twilio isn't "mostly anonymous," what is? And why the heck does having subscriber data available via court order eliminate something from the "mostly anonymous" category? edit: by the way, I never said '"anonymous" simply means it's not listed anywhere'
- emodendroket 9y agoYou can't see the difference between something where it's difficult to even figure out who the user is and something else where anonymity depends entirely on you trusting the service provider and them not being subject to a court order?
- justin66 9y agoAt a nesting depth of six or seven comments, is it really productive to reply with rhetorical questions that don't even respond to the comment? Of course I can see the difference. I just don't understand what it is about the level of privacy that comes from requiring a court order to access user information that moves a service from "mostly anonymous" to "not anonymous at all." It seems like a highly ideological rather than a practical position to take.
- emodendroket 9y agoIf you care about anonymity because you're, I don't know, some sort of dissident, then the kind of anonymity offered here is absolutely useless.
- justin66 9y agoI'm sure we can all agree that "mostly anonymous" isn't good enough for a dissident, but holy fuck what a useless subthread you started. Or I started. Dear God.