3 ms·
I actually found it to be an inspiring read about why higher taxes on the rich may be a bad idea (ie. it's not likely that the government would do a better job
by dasil003 16y ago
I actually found it to be an inspiring read about why higher taxes on the rich may be a bad idea (ie. it's not likely that the government would do a better job spending the money).
However a glaring omission (one of many I suppose) is the chilling effect that wealth-holders can have on innovation by wielding legal and political power. I don't have a problem with lowering taxes on the rich, but first lets see what we can do about insulating the political process from monied interests.
- nickpinkston 16y agoQuite true - the problem we have is not capitalism; it's corporatism: the alliance of corporate oligarchs and the state.
- stretchwithme 16y agoexactly. government slanted in favor of anybody is trouble for everybody else.
- naradaellis 16y agoJohn Ralston Saul's book Unconscious Civilization (a kind of primer on his theories I think, which one would read before they tackle Voltaire's Bastards) does a wonderful job of elaborating this point, anyone interested in an article such as this would do well to read the book, Capitalism - real capitalism, not the cowardice we see masquarading as capitalism a lot of the time - is fine, corporatism and the power we give corps. by surrendring to them is what is dismantling democracy and individual liberty. (And Ralston Saul posits that this is an age-old battle, whether it be corps. in their modern form, or as in the Catholic Church).
- brazzy 16y agowhat we can do about insulating the political process from monied interests. Absolutely nothing. Money is power. It's nothing more and nothing less than a societywide promise that people will give you things and do things for you. Trying to prevent the imbalance in money-power from being reflected to a large degree in political power is ultimately futile. Any rules you make will have loopholes and workarounds for those in possession of enough money-power.
- dasil003 16y agoYes money is power, but government is a cultural institution. We already have ethical and legal rules against corruption, they just need to be strengthened at a societal level. Saying 'absolutely nothing' can be done is a defeatist attitude. It's fine for money to be used for influence within the rules of the system, but when it's used to fix the rules, that goes against everyone's interests. It also behooves the rich to acknowledge the value of a fair playing field since consolidating too much power often leads to violent revolution (ie. instant nullification of the power-value of money by the masses).