3 ms·
There's another proposed solution to this problem in the form of tax reform - The Fair Tax proposal. IANA Tax Expert, but I like how they've completely rethoug
by SkyMarshal 16y ago
There's another proposed solution to this problem in the form of tax reform - The Fair Tax proposal.
IANA Tax Expert, but I like how they've completely rethought the tax system from the ground up, with the objective of making the US a tax haven for all parts of the manufacturing process - harvesting raw materials, milling into useful materials, manufacturing into products, transport, and sales.
In a nutshell, there are 'embedded taxes' at every point in the manufacturing chain. Take a simplified semiconductor for example, made of sand, aluminum, and copper:
1. Mine the copper and aluminum, collect the sand (payroll + income + other taxes)
2. Purify it all, mill the copper and aluminum (payroll + income + other taxes)
3. Deliver to fabrication facilities (tax the transport company)
4. Convert sand to silicon wafers, etch the microprocessors into the wafers with the copper and aluminum, package into chips. (more taxes)
5. Transport to OEMs (tax the transport company)
6. Build computers (more taxes)
7. FedEx/UPS to purchaser (more taxes).
The consumer ends up paying multiple embedded taxes in the final cost of the product. The Fair Tax folks estimate that these embedded taxes comprise roughly 22% of the cost of the average product manufactured in the US.
The Fair Tax would instead remove all the embedded taxes and add them in one lump sum to the final product:
1. Mine the copper and aluminum, collect the sand (no tax)
2. Purify it all, mill the copper and aluminum (no tax)
3. Deliver to fabrication facilities (no tax)
4. Convert sand to silicon wafers, etch the microprocessors into the wafers with the copper and aluminum, package into chips. (no tax)
5. Transport to OEMs (no tax)
6. Build computers (no tax)
7. FedEx/UPS to purchaser (no tax).
8. Consumer pays 23% tax (calculated inclusively, 30% calculated exclusively) on the final product.
The final cost to the US consumer is roughly the same, but the incentives are drastically realigned. It becomes much less expensive to make things in the US, and they are only taxed when sold in the US. Products exported overseas would be tax-free to make and sell (except for taxes in the foreign countries).
The concept potentially solves all sorts of problems, from our trade balance to illegal immigrants not paying taxes. Definitely worth reading more about for anyone interested:
http://www.fairtax.org/ http://www.fairtax.org/
http://www.amazon.com/FairTax-Answering-Critics-Neal-Boortz/dp/0061540463 http://www.amazon.com/FairTax-Answering-Critics-Neal-Boortz/...
http://www.amazon.com/FairTax-Solution-Financial-Justice-Americans/dp/1595230602/ http://www.amazon.com/FairTax-Solution-Financial-Justice-Ame...
- aero142 16y agoI really like the fair tax, but it bothers me that it is regressive. I know it is the same % for everyone, and there is the rebate at the poverty line, but the wealthy spend a much smaller percentage of their money at the retail level. Why is buying a car taxed but buying a company isn't? I've heard different answers but I'm not convinced by any of them.
- brg 16y agoEverything is taxed, services as well as investments. What do you think will become of the accumulated wealth, that it will forever remain in bank accounts? What good would it be to have it and not have it moving through the system? It will eventually get taxed, perhaps simple not as fast as you wish. Its only regressive when you lose perspective on the purpose of money.
- piguy314 16y agoFair tax is a great idea, it's basically a lot like a VAT or border adjustment tariff that most countries already have. VAT applies to domestic consumption and imports but not exports, this is one way to encourage exports (China already does this). Anyway, the reasons the fair tax will not be adopted are: 1. Too many special interests benefit from the current tax structure: -Charities -Accountants/CPA firms and their lobbies -Large corporations who pay a very low effective tax rate -Rich people 2. The government LIKES a complex tax system with different tax treatment for different types of people and tax credits which they can use to "shape behavior" 3. Progressives always cry "Regressive tax" when we aren't appearing to tax the rich proportionately more than the poor. News flash guys the rich are smarter than you and avoid paying most of their taxes already by using personal corporations to hold their wealth. Also as has already been stated the fair tax has a cost of living rebate for poor people. 4. It would make too much sense, and we can't do anything that makes sense in America, that's just downright unamerican. Also can we please stop pretending "creative destruction" and blatant mercantilism and market manipulation by the chinese are the same thing. China doesn't believe in free market capitalism, they never have, they never will, they have a planned economy and manipulate their currency and subsidize factories to create large amounts of manufacturing wealth. This is not the same thing as buggy whip makers going out of business, this is the wholesale destruction of the American manufacturing economy to the benefit of the chinese. We need an import tariff on ONLY chinese goods UNTIL they stop manipulating the currency. The tarif should be the same amount by which they have devalued their currency, about 40 percent. All of you trade hawks screaming about trade war seem to believe we only trade with China, this is obviously false. If we don't levy tariffs on anybody else things will be fine, we'll just buy crap from viet nam, south america and south korea until china falls into line with their currency policy. Sure China will retaliate against us, but we'll still be selling stuff to every other country who's name isn't China.