3 ms·
There is a very big and rather obvious issue of trust with a solution like theirs. I am expected to entrust them with my passwords, essentially creating a singl
by huhtenberg 19y ago
There is a very big and rather obvious issue of trust with a solution like theirs. I am expected to entrust them with my passwords, essentially creating a single point of failure for a lot of sensitive information. Sorry, can't do. Not even if they were a spin-off of VeriSign.
The only passwords I am willing to share with them at the moment are those I am finding at BugMeNot :)
- spolsky 19y agoWouldn't it be possible to create a site that remembers all your passwords but only has them in encrypted form? It would use JavaScript on the browser to encrypt and decrypt the passwords (using your master passphrase) before sending them to the server?
- simonw 19y agoClient-side encryption wouldn't protect you against that site turning evil and deciding to steal your passwords - they'd just have to change their code to decrypt your passwords and then post them back to the server.
- spolsky 19y agoBut they could be audited by looking at the JavaScript, so at least you have a way to prove to yourself they're legit.
- brlewis 19y agoHow many sites do you use with "I forgot my password" features that send you email? Email is that exact single point of failure for most people.
- huhtenberg 19y agoNo, it is not. The only place where the email can actually be a single point of anything is either my local Inbox or an Inbox at my mail provider. Latter is temporary, so compromising provider's systems does not jeopardize all my web accounts. And compromised local Inbox is an indication of a far more serious security breach, not isolated to the email. So, no, your analogy is wrong.
- simonw 19y agoI don't see your point. If I steal the password for your e-mail somehow, I can access your inbox (through webmail or POP or whatever) and then use "I forgot my password" on sites you use to steal your accounts there. If you use webmail and don't delete your e-mail I can search through your inbox to figure out what those sites are. Seems like a pretty serious single point of failure to me.
- huhtenberg 19y agoIf Clickpass servers are compromised, then so will be all my web accounts. And I have no reason to believe they will not be. That's the point.
- justindz 19y agoSo, in a nutshell, you trust ClickPass security less than you trust your email provider's security. And, the margin is great enough to overcome whatever ease-of-use gains you might get from ClickPass over email. Did I get that right?
- huhtenberg 19y agoPartially. There are attacks that specifically target me and there are attacks that are going after anyone with login credentials. The issue with ClickPass is that it wants to be choke full of latter guys. This makes it a fat and juicy target for someone looking to grab any credentials. The question of my trust in my email provider here is secondary. It is only relevant if I am personally the ultimate target. See the difference ? The bottom line is that they want to manage my confidential information. This is very ballsy of them and it comes with a LOT of responsibility whether they realize it or not. Or, perhaps, they want to deal with passwords that are OK to be compromised. In former case they (currently) lack credibility, in latter case they misrepresent what their service is about. Hence my original comment.
- immad 19y agoIf you have different secure passwords at every single website and some how avoid email as a single point of failure then Clickpass/OpenID might not be the right solution for you. For everyone else its better then whats currently out there, and we are going to implement further security measures going forward.
- huhtenberg 19y agoEmail is not a single point of failure as I just explained in another reply and Internet users with rudimental sense of security is not a rarity. I'm afraid the ignorant "everyone else" crowd you are planning to cater to might not be as big as you expect it to be. Also you are tasking yourselves with handling confidential information, so stating that your "lips are sealed and encrypted" is not good enough. I fail to see how this is "better then whats currently out there". Sorry to be peeing in your punch on a launch day, but you do have a serious problem with a security disclosure.
- immad 19y ago1. If your email servers are compromised, than it makes them a single point of failure as most web accounts are accessible through forgotten password procedures. 2. Most people (66%) of users use the same password on all websites. Which is a far worse multiple trusted party single point of failure. Which is what I meant by "better than whats currently out there". 3. For services that really require a significantly increased level of security, like banks, it is very easy and likely that further security measures that don't rely on the OpenID provider will be built in on the websites. 4. It is important to figure out the security issue and make a rewarding web experience than hold up ones hands and decrease data portability and increase friction on the web. We are hoping to help that process along and are very open to suggestions on how we can improve that.