5 ms·
If you’re renting a city apt. without a car, 16% of your rent pays for parking
- imgabe 9y agoWhere is parking included? Every building in my city that has a garage charges $200+ per month for parking in addition to rent.
- harigov 9y agoExactly. Such an easy way of increasing rent without actually increasing it.
- didgeoridoo 9y agoI don't think they're talking about reserved spots. The issue is with the government-mandated "parking requirement" that forces builders to account for a certain number of parking spots per person as part of getting a project approved. The analysis is about how much this requirement increases development costs, which are then passed on to all tenants equally.
- curun1r 9y agoI think GP's post was saying that they're not passed on evenly. Developers in many cities have realized that they can satisfy the requirements and charge extra for those parking spaces, whether assigned or not. I've lived in at least 2 buildings that had mixed assigned/unassigned parking and residents could choose whether to pay more for assigned, but unassigned spaces still cost extra. In both cases, not having a car would have saved me at least $200/mo.
- valuearb 9y agoAs a libertarian who loves the freedom my car affords me, I hate that governments are mandating building parking spaces. Let the market provide, if everyone downtown wants to walk, ride a bike or take a bus/tram then more power to them.
- blacksmith_tb 9y agoIsn't that freedom mostly an illusion? I suppose you can hop in the car for an impromptu road trip whenever you like, but you are paying to license, insure, and maintain the car 24/7/365... and most people can't take too many road trips. But I am trying to picture the market providing if there weren't parking requirements - would a neighborhood reach a point where car owners wanting to move in would pay so much to park that it'd make sense to knock down buildings and put up a parking lot? I suppose that would act as a sort of brake on the whole cycle, since there'd be less housing.
- gozur88 9y agoDevelopers would include parking garages if it was something that raised the rents they could charge. These kinds of rules are usually enacted by people who have lived in a city for a long time and always parked on the street for free. There's some new development and all of the sudden they can't find a space. So they push through rules that force new development to include parking.
- valuearb 9y agoin my case work is 22 miles one direction, my daughters schools 15 miles in a different direction. I live in a state that prioritized roads and because of that my commute is fast and easy.
- tmnvix 9y agoAssuming each workday you travel to drop your child at school, then to work, then back to collect your child, then home, you will be travelling (15 + 15 + 22 + 22 + 15 + 15) x 5 = 520 miles each week. I'm sure you have come to some other arrangement but holy shit that would be a lot of time spent travelling each week. It's worth working out how much time you need to spend at work to pay for the fuel, maintenance, and depreciation involved because that is essentially also 'travel time'. edit: Even assuming an average speed of 50km/h that is about 16.5 hours each week. Including time spent earning the money to cover the associated costs it's going to be over 20 hours.
- Mz 9y agoI rented an apartment for five years that came with an assigned spot. I wasn't there all that long when I gave up my car. All the neighbors were like "Yay! Free space!" My rent did not drop. I felt all kinds of shit all over. Parking spaces should be extra or people without cars should get a discount.
- chaosbutters314 9y agoWell, if they built the parking with the apartment I see no problem in the landlord charging tenants for the spot and letting them sublet it with the help of the landlord. If you didn't want the spot with the place, should've chosen another one.
- Mz 9y agoIf you didn't want the spot with the place, should've chosen another one. There is all kinds of stuff wrong with this statement. A) It was the only apartment complex that met my needs. B) I don't think there were any apartment complexes where a parking space was optional. C) As I said above: I had a car when I rented the place. I gave it up later. That was not in my plans at the time that I rented the place.
- JadeNB 9y ago> C) As I said above: I had a car when I rented the place. I gave it up later. That was not in my plans at the time that I rented the place. Without commenting on (A) or (B), surely (C) is not a reasonable complaint? If you rent a 2-bedroom, but then your roommate moves out, then certainly it was not in your plans at the time that you rented, but just as certainly you wouldn't expect your rent to go down. (I recognise that it's a different situation, since no-one can readily use the other bedroom, whereas someone can use the parking space; but what I mean is that "That was not in my plans" is not in itself a justification for a rent abatement.)
- Mz 9y agoIt isn't a complaint. It is a rebuttal of a completely ridiculous assertion that I should not have rented the place to begin with.
- counterpoint1 9y agoIt's fascinating to see the massive propaganda campaign ridesharing companies are launching against parking spots. You do all understand that's where the massive wave of articles about changing building codes and zoning rules to get rid of parking, both public and privately owned, is coming from, right? Uber, Lyft, etc would love to make it hard or impossible to use a privately owned car in urban areas. Getting rid of the requirement to put parking will mostly just lower everyone's quality of life- residents will take up all the street parking, making it harder for shoppers to access stores, restaurants, etc, making brick and mortar stores even further disadvantaged versus online retailers while also causing more headaches as businesses are forced to actively police their parking areas against use by non-customers. But it'll be great news for ride sharing companies, as millions of people find themselves unable to own a car while living in American cities which are entirely designed to require car travel.
- rayiner 9y agoThere is no conceivable market failure here that would require regulation of parking spaces. The market will build the amount of parking people want. If the amount of parking goes down it'll be because the land is valued more highly for other uses.
- closeparen 9y agoZoning and height limits are experiencing no such liberalization. Previously we had a decent equilibrium system: low density but also a system of transportation well suited to low density. Now that system of transportation is being decommissioned, but we're still stuck with low density. How many hours of productivity must employers lose to their workers' long commutes? Yet the market has not provided us with anything faster.
- eesmith 9y ago"Previously we had a decent equilibrium system" The system we had was not in equilibrium because: 1) The cost of maintaining the old system was predicated on a continuous growth which hasn't occurred. This is the "Growth Ponzi Scheme" - https://www.strongtowns.org/the-growth-ponzi-scheme/ https://www.strongtowns.org/the-growth-ponzi-scheme/ . 2) the Baby Boomers are now reaching retirement age. As they get older, they will be less able to drive, making it difficult for them to live in low density areas even if there were no infrastructure problems. What does mandatory minimum parking have to do with workers' long commutes? Presumably if employee time is important to the employer then the employer will pay for parking spaces even if there were no minimum parking requirements.
- stolk 9y agoSo what if you don't have a car: No car, but a parking space assigned to your condo/apt? Just rent it out to a neighbour with two cars, and you get those $150,- per month right back. Problem solved. I rented an additional space in my building for my motorcycle. Happy renter, happy parking-space-landlord.
- nmcfarl 9y agoUNH bnj
- ryanx435 9y agoY'all complaining about the price of parking seriously need to consider moving to a city with lower costs of living. Ive got a 2 bedroom upper level duplex in Minneapolis with a 1 stall garage and 1 additional off street parking space, located on a block with ample street parking, and is only 1 block away from a bus stop on a major bus line that i take to work, all for $1100 a month.
- alphabettsy 9y agoHuh. He last two major cities I lived in I payed extra for parking on top of my rent as did most others I knew. How’s it work in that scenario.
- alphabettsy 9y agoHuh. The last two major cities I lived in I payed extra for parking on top of my rent as did most others I knew. How’s it work in that scenario.