12 ms·

This looks promising and fairly well done, but it's lacking a few critical features IMO. The first obvious one is a way to Diff a recipe and it's Forks (unless

This looks promising and fairly well done, but it's lacking a few critical features IMO. The first obvious one is a way to Diff a recipe and it's Forks (unless I missed that). The harder and maybe more important one, is an issue that GitHub itself still hasn't figured out how to solve either. There should be a process for a fork of a recipe being able to explain why it is better than the original, and have the fork be able to be voted on so that the 'best' fork as voted by the most users becomes the canonical 'Chicken Noodle Soup' recipe, or at least display the forks on main recipe ranked by popularity.

keithasaurus 9y ago
Yeah, it's on the list of things to do. Once there are enough recipes/users it will also be useful to see the history/ancestry of recipe. There are already a few that are forks of forks. All the recipe data is immutable and versioned, so that will happen at some point.
- jitl 9y ago
  A++ would love to see the diff feature :)
ghayes 9y ago
My first thought was to remove "Vegan Butter" from the chicken recipe (or move it into a "Dietary Substitutions"), but then I realized my forked recipe would probably just be lost in the void. Maybe the goal of forks should be more akin to pull requests?
- colordrops 9y ago
  Seems that "Dietary Substitutions" could be a first-class data type. It would be a named multi-map of one item to another one. So you could create you own "Dietary Substitution Map" named "Nut allergies" or "Halal" or "Vegan", with butter -> canola oil, milk -> soy milk, milk -> almond milk, etc. Then you could pick the particular substitution map that you care about and avoid forking recipes unnecessarily and have most recipes support most diet types if the proper map exists.
  - keithasaurus 9y ago
    Interesting idea. I can think of a few ways it would get complicated pretty quickly, but it's probably 90% doable without too much effort.
tedmiston 9y ago
> There should be a process for a fork of a recipe being able to explain why it is better than the original, and have the fork be able to be voted on That'd be a nice edition to GitHub's forks page. Over there star count might be the best proxy.
- melicerte 9y ago
  I though the README.md and project stars was there for that precise reason. Am I wrong ?
  - tedmiston 9y ago
    On source repos, you're right. On forked repos, people often don't change the readme, and to see star repo counts of forks requires opening each repo individually.
JoshTriplett 9y ago
> There should be a process for a fork of a recipe being able to explain why it is better than the original, and have the fork be able to be voted on so that the 'best' fork as voted by the most users becomes the canonical 'Chicken Noodle Soup' recipe, or at least display the forks on main recipe ranked by popularity. A combination of popularity and the ability to choose to merge changes back into the original seems sufficient.
- deleted 9y ago
  [deleted]
roryisok 9y ago
"forks" is so fitting here

keithasaurus 9y ago

Yeah, it's on the list of things to do. Once there are enough recipes/users it will also be useful to see the history/ancestry of recipe. There are already a few that are forks of forks. All the recipe data is immutable and versioned, so that will happen at some point.

jitl 9y ago
A++ would love to see the diff feature :)

ghayes 9y ago

My first thought was to remove "Vegan Butter" from the chicken recipe (or move it into a "Dietary Substitutions"), but then I realized my forked recipe would probably just be lost in the void. Maybe the goal of forks should be more akin to pull requests?

colordrops 9y ago
Seems that "Dietary Substitutions" could be a first-class data type. It would be a named multi-map of one item to another one. So you could create you own "Dietary Substitution Map" named "Nut allergies" or "Halal" or "Vegan", with butter -> canola oil, milk -> soy milk, milk -> almond milk, etc. Then you could pick the particular substitution map that you care about and avoid forking recipes unnecessarily and have most recipes support most diet types if the proper map exists.
- keithasaurus 9y ago
  Interesting idea. I can think of a few ways it would get complicated pretty quickly, but it's probably 90% doable without too much effort.

tedmiston 9y ago

> There should be a process for a fork of a recipe being able to explain why it is better than the original, and have the fork be able to be voted on That'd be a nice edition to GitHub's forks page. Over there star count might be the best proxy.

melicerte 9y ago
I though the README.md and project stars was there for that precise reason. Am I wrong ?
- tedmiston 9y ago
  On source repos, you're right. On forked repos, people often don't change the readme, and to see star repo counts of forks requires opening each repo individually.

JoshTriplett 9y ago

> There should be a process for a fork of a recipe being able to explain why it is better than the original, and have the fork be able to be voted on so that the 'best' fork as voted by the most users becomes the canonical 'Chicken Noodle Soup' recipe, or at least display the forks on main recipe ranked by popularity. A combination of popularity and the ability to choose to merge changes back into the original seems sufficient.

deleted 9y ago
[deleted]

roryisok 9y ago

"forks" is so fitting here