4 ms·
Heh. My second project at my first employer out of college (back in 2006) was building a system to detect violations of this rule (Reg NMS, if you're curious).
by nostrademons 9y ago
Heh. My second project at my first employer out of college (back in 2006) was building a system to detect violations of this rule (Reg NMS, if you're curious). We found that there were trade-throughs happening on a daily basis, it was so common that it appeared to be just how the markets worked.
Tried to sell it to the SEC and they weren't interested.
Then we pivoted to try to sell to traders, so they could prove to clients that they were getting the best execution possible (or occasionally better than the best possible, but that gets washed out of the aggregate stats). They were very interested, until the data showed that most of the ones who don't already have a proprietary version of this were actually doing terribly on their trade executions. Then they weren't interested at all.
I ended up leaving the company - and the financial industry - at that point. My take-away from the whole experience is that the game really is rigged. I remember reading a non-mainstream economics paper in college that modeled the world not in terms of price equilibria or value-add, but assumed that all actors were basically bandits who would try to take whatever they could by force or deceit. It was horribly depressing at the time, but it actually seems like a more accurate model of how the world really works, the remarkable part being that democratic capitalism has managed to channel the impulses of those bandits (while still being utterly crooked) into a system that on a macro-level basically kinda/sorta works.
- neuronexmachina 9y ago> I remember reading a non-mainstream economics paper in college that modeled the world not in terms of price equilibria or value-add, but assumed that all actors were basically bandits who would try to take whatever they could by force or deceit. If you can find the paper I'd love to see it.
- nostrademons 9y agoOoh, I think I got closer, though I still haven't found the exact paper. Search for the work of Mancur Olson. I think "Dictatorship, Democracy, and Development" was the paper, but I just got a JStor link, so I'm not sure it was exactly it.
- justadeveloper2 9y agoI disagree that it works--it's just that it hasn't utterly failed yet. Big difference. If you look at failed states, the bandits won. Argentina comes to mind, maybe Venezuela. Brazil is headed there.
- nostrademons 9y agoHaving "not utterly failed" for 240 years is a fairly big accomplishment, precisely because the lifespan of many other societal organizing principles is about equal to a human lifespan (~80 years).
- jerrylives 9y agoUh it kinda failed big time in the '20s and '30s
- r00fus 9y agoThe results were War, big ones at that. So a pretty bad failure mode for millions.
- carapace 9y ago> Having "not utterly failed" for 240 years is a fairly big accomplishment No. Not even a little. The dinosaurs lasted more than a million times as long. If we talking hominids do not last half a billion years or more we are pathetic losers.
- minimax 9y agoThe article isn't about trade throughs. It's an unconvincing argument that rebates bad and that IEX is good because it does not use rebates (while failing to mention any other exchanges that don't pay rebates).
- michaelwsherman 9y agoI did some regulatory work as well, for an upcoming regulation called Reg CAT. CAT will require all brokers, traders, exchanges, etc. to report essentially everything that happens--orders, cancellations, trade executions, etc. Right now the SEC really has no way to catch the majority of regulatory hijinx (look at the years-long attempt to track down the cause of the 2010 "flash crash"). Hopefully this will improve the ability to regulate in the future. But it probably won't result in significantly more enforcement--the regulation is written in such a way that the exchanges and FINRA will carry the primary regulatory burden rather the SEC itself. This means that despite there soon being a system that could, say, give you every reg NMS violation via a database query matched to a log of historical latencies, very little will likely change.