7 ms·
Jeff Sessions Announces Justice Department Will Increase Asset Forfeiture
- forgottenacc57 9y agoCan I say this? What a fucked up country.
- ende 9y agoNo, you can't. But you can say "what a fucked up federal administration".
- knieveltech 9y agoIf you think this is limited to the federal administration I recommend you spend some time investigating the kinds of lunacy that are afoot in state legislatures in places like Kansas, Massachusetts, North Carolina, and Texas (et al).
- geff82 9y agoWhat you currently see, and I find it dramatic: the anglo-saxon world is in decline. Canada, Ireland, Australia and New Zealand might be alive and kicking, but they represent only a minority of people in the anglo-saxon world. This decline shows itself in people like Trump or the Brexit.
- mythrwy 9y agoPerhaps Trump and Brexit are (likely misguided) attempts to stop the decline rather than the actual decline itself?
- geff82 9y agoOf course you can stop ageing by killing yourself...
- geff82 9y agoOk, not joking now. What Britain and USA are currently doing is giving up power. They have so much internal conflicts that somehow people feel getting on their own will help them. But giving up power rarely made a nation larger and stronger. So they are declining. USA could have been the master of TPP or TTIP, or create some Euro-American superstructure in rememberance of our common roots. They could have been the leader of many things. But instead they just leave and go away. No negocitations. The world will not stop, it will go on, everything else is hallucination. The Chinese are ready to fill the void, and Europe is already bonding with them now that the US don't seem to be interested in anything constructive. So there is no stopping the decline. It is in full speed and it will lead to ugly situations. And as someone who loves(d) the US, this is a pity to me.
- mythrwy 9y agoWell to be fair some people blame the decline on an increase in minorities and pot smoking hipsters. But I'm generally skeptical of "reasons" because people seem to want always blame everyone else. Besides, I think the "decline" is a bit overstated. America isn't going anywhere. Things start getting tough and the guns will come out and they have a lot of those. Besides maybe Anglo Saxons shouldn't rule the whole world. And really nothing lasts forever. China might supplant the west as global leader, this was predicted I think two centuries ago, but it won't happen for a while.
- s_dev 9y agoAnglo-sphere maybe in decline but I see a positive future for western civilisation. EU is looking more and more impressive the more it gets compared to the US or UK.
- mrleiter 9y agoCapitalism works because there is an elected authority, the U.S. Governement, that guarantees its citizens their right to own property. Property is one of the fundamental pillars of Western society. Under certain formal processes, property can be taken away (without the consent of the owner). The motivation behind such drastic actions is to balance out economic interests of the involved parties, e.g. in lien those of debtor vs creditor. Or when the government needs to build a road and a land owner is unwillig to sell, there must be a fair process, which must balance the need of the public as well. So, now, asset forfeiture can be a useful tool to undermine criminal activity (or any activity really) of a specific person. But this must happen in a fair trial (unless danger is imminent, under which one can argue in favor of indemnity). In this case there hasn't even been a charge brought forward. This alone is executive abuse of power, because a independent judicial system must only be allowed to take such actions. Moreover, this will hit economically weak peak people hardest. Which further increases crime. It's a vicious circle.
- abhi3 9y agoNot an American but reading all the outrage gives me the impression that police in US is just going around seizing a couple of thousand dollars from anyone they can find to fill up their budget and hope no one will go to court because it'd be more expensive for the accused to hire a lawyer. Nevermind that contingency fee arrangments are widespread and that small amounts of cash, even to the extent of a few tens of thousand dollars can easily be proved as legitimate money if one has a job. Not familiar with US civil procedure but it should involve showing your tax returns and asking for a summary judgment, and later a tort lawsuit against the State for all the suffering caused. I would be interested in knowing the median amount seized by police in such cases. Maybe its just a case of politicians one after another not being ideologues about property right but recognizing the merits of adopting a pragmatist approach to augment law enforcement budget by seizing large amounts of obviously ill gotten wealth without having to discharge a high (and expensive) burden of proof in each case. If so, sounds good to me.
- arjuan 9y agoIf you want additional perspective on how it's actually used, then checkout John Oliver's segment on Civil Forfeiture.
- meddlepal 9y agoGovernment in this country is completely off the rails insane. At least ten-fifteen, heck twenty years ago you could sort of understand why certain policy decisions were made... nowadays it is like completely impossible to figure out what people in power are trying to actually accomplish.
- Finnucane 9y agoReally? It doesn't seem that hard to understand what motivates Jeff Sessions--filling up private prisons and using police to terrorize poor and minority communities.
- spoiledtechie 9y agoa bit bias I think you are. I voted you down because this isn't a productive conversation.
- freddealmeida 9y agothe evidence speaks for itself. bias seems to be a norm in american politic
- harpiaharpyja 9y agoI suppose then the mystery has now shifted to why no one is seemingly doing anything about it? I hope that does not come across as sardonic. If a functional mechanism to curb these kinds of excesses does not exist anymore, that is something which we will have to come to terms with as a society.
- sremani 9y agoThe nickname for (former AG under Obama) Loretta Lynch was Queen of Forfeiture, and has a body of work reflecting this when she was working in Brooklyn. It would be insane to think that civil forfeiture was not a problem the past 8 years.
- specializeded 9y ago
- thebiglebrewski 9y agoJeff Sessions is like an evil caricature of what an Attorney General should be. I hope this whole administration goes down and soon. The war on drugs failed decades ago, let's focus on rehabilitation and getting people back to society and things to be excited about instead of drugs (but wait, that problem is so much harder to solve!) On a trip to Montreal this weekend I seriously considered just staying...
- scurvy 9y agoI don't like Mr. Sessions, nor do I like asset forfeiture, but I'd like to know more about the efficacy of rehab before heading down that path. I asked for some stats about rehab in the recent opioid epidemic thread, but I didn't receive any. Even as everyone threw forward ideas about free state sponsored heroin and rehab programs. I really would like to see some stats before forming an opinion on emotions alone. After all, it was emotions that landed us here. Some people just don't want to rejoin society. Why choose life when you've got heroin? Pretty sure that rehab doesn't have a good success rate in those situations.
- maxerickson 9y agoThere's no tidy table, but "75% drop" sounds promising. http://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2017/04/18/524380027/in-portugal-drug-use-is-treated-as-a-medical-issue-not-a-crime http://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2017/04/18/524380027/i... Especially when coupled with "cheaper".
- scurvy 9y agoYeah, I'm really looking for a good study that isn't behind a medical pay wall or requires professional creds to read. The 95% drop in HIV is a great side stat, but really looking more on stats for rehab programs.
- maxerickson 9y agoThey instituted mandatory treatment for people found with personal use amounts of drugs and then but it's actually a 75 percent drop from the 1990s. I suppose what I am suggesting is that this is sufficient evidence for you to stop casting doubt and go find evidence for it if you want to continue questioning treatment. Otherwise you get to argue by shouting at the monkeys to dance as you demand ever higher quality proof that you are wrong.
- jerrylives 9y agoDisgusting. Everyone in Congress who voted this monster into office should be ashamed of themselves.
- xamuel 9y agoForfeiture is disgusting, but what Congress really should be ashamed of is their own inaction in addressing forfeiture through legislation. It's not like Sessions is some dark age monarch answerable to no-one. Forfeiture continues because Congress hasn't outlawed it.
- lallysingh 9y agoAnd the courts.
- squozzer 9y agoIt's an obvious admission as to the sorry state of the nation's finances.
- maxerickson 9y agoThat would be a really stupid reason to increase asset forfeitures. Like, deeply incompetent and unable to engage in clear thinking about the budget stupid. Even if you don't bother to exclude things like the Madoff case (which was a huge seizure and didn't really go towards government spending...), asset forfeitures aren't going to make the tiniest dent in the budget deficit (on the order of 0.1%...). Never mind the debt.
- Crontab 9y agoSessions is so out of touch it's insane.
- sbuttgereit 9y agoWhile I appreciate that it is in vogue to bash Trump & Co. (Largely justified I would agree), we would be mistaken to couch this as something new or some difference between the mainstream political parties. Sessions predecessor had no problem with asset forfeiture either: https://www.usnews.com/opinion/articles/2016-04-11/obamas-doj-sets-back-justice-with-asset-forfeiture-program https://www.usnews.com/opinion/articles/2016-04-11/obamas-do...
- rndmize 9y agoThere's a difference between "no problem with" and "actively encouraging". It's similar to how the millions of people we now have in prison as a result of three strikes laws and heavy drug enforcement that was popular politically in the 80s and 90s has come to be seen as a bad and ineffective thing - and yet a few months ago Sessions released a statement saying the DOJ recommended pursuing maximum sentencing. > Sessions also formally withdrew a signature part of Attorney General Eric Holder's "Smart on Crime" initiative, which sought to target the most serious crimes and reduce the number of defendants charged with non-violent drug offenses that would otherwise trigger mandatory minimum sentences. http://www.cnn.com/2017/05/12/politics/sessions-criminal-charging-memo/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2017/05/12/politics/sessions-criminal-cha... Without even considering the rest of the Trump administration, Sessions is taking this country backwards and encouraging policies we already know don't work.
- sbuttgereit 9y agoIn the US News article I posted, AG Lynch was actively encouraging the practice by reviving the equitable sharing program. A program designed to be sure those that collect the loot get their cut. My informal turn of phrase notwithstanding, the so-called progressives are just as regressive on this issue add their conservative counterparts.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- snsr 9y agoThis practice (brought back to life by Reagan's "Comprehensive Crime Control Act of 1984") is not only unjust but unconstitutional at face value. The cynicism required to double down on this practice is a new low for Sessions, something I didn't think was possible.
- cleansy 9y agoSoon you have to consider Asset Forfeiture as a 'hidden' tax on the economy. Same when 'revolutionary forces' condemn land from farmers or dictators disown factory owners.
- aaronchall 9y agoThis is a good point, and I don't think we see enough economics perspective on this subject. The problem is that "Asset Forfeiture" appears to work in making drug dealing (and other black market criminal activities) a much more risky business. The question is how do we balance something that works with restoring property to law-abiding citizens when police make a mistake? There seems to be little to no process around this. There will be resistance to installing processes because criminals will use it to reclaim their dirty money and more process will cost time and money, making forfeiture less effective.
- syshum 9y ago>>The problem is that "Asset Forfeiture" appears to work in making drug dealing (and other black market criminal activities) a much more risky business. Citation, I have read alot of reports and studies on this subject none of them support our position
- DenisM 9y agoJustice Thomas indicated he will vote to strike down the law should the case be brought before him. With him having said that soon enough a lawyer will appear to argue the case, this practice will not last. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2017/03/06/justice-thomas-sharply-criticizes-civil-forfeiture-laws/?utm_term=.3ca89de8853b https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/201...
- Overtonwindow 9y agoI only hope this increase will lead to the increase in lawsuits, and judicial review of this awful practice.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]