3 ms·
Something else I am not the first to notice: the "magic spot" problem doesn't affect Edge. It really makes me wonder if there is an underlying software or firm
by KirinDave 16y ago
Something else I am not the first to notice: the "magic spot" problem doesn't affect Edge.
It really makes me wonder if there is an underlying software or firmware issue that is exacerbating the problem. The fact that upload isn't significantly impacted, nor Edge, suggests some sort of phone freakout that's not strictly dictated by the hardware to me.
- mechanical_fish 16y agoThe "magic spot" "problem" does not affect the Edge band for this particular user, in this particular location, on this particular day, in this particular phase of the moon. Antenna design is black magic on the best of days. When you mix in all the variables at play across three million phone users around the country you get lots of irreproducible results. What I find myself wondering is: Sure, closely coupling a big bag of saltwater (e.g. me) to the phone may [1] tend to reduce the antenna efficiency relative to leaving the phone alone on a table. But can I strap the iPhone into some sort of specially-designed case that's designed to increase the antenna efficiency? [1] EDIT: This word used to be "will", but having just read Anandtech's fun analysis of this "problem", I am reminded that what giveth in one waveband taketh away in another: Anand improved his WiFi signal power under certain conditions by gripping the phone.
- KirinDave 16y agoThat is a very optimistic idea. I wouldn't have mentioned the edge thing except that I've heard that sentiment repeated a lot, and I've asked other people for confirmation.
- mtm 16y agoCan't say much about Edge, but I assume that the upload speeds are mostly unaffected because that is mostly transmitted data from the phone (though it would be interesting to see if the phone is cranking up the transmit power when the antenna is shorted)
- tcdent 16y agoAside from being in control of it's power, why would transmitting behave any differently?
- kylec 16y agoI live in an Edge-only area and I'm affected by the problem.