2 ms·
> Archive.org is exempt from certain aspects of copyright Achive.org isn't exempt from anything, at least not in the U.S. Their actual _archiving_ of web conte
by wahern 9y ago
> Archive.org is exempt from certain aspects of copyright
Achive.org isn't exempt from anything, at least not in the U.S. Their actual _archiving_ of web content might be considered Fair Use, but that's distinct from a right to redistribute such archived content to third parties, which in turn is distinct from your right to make copies (e.g. to create and maintain a copy on your hard drive by downloading the file.)
Ultimately, as regards the law of copyright, it doesn't much matter _how_ you acquired the content. What matters is if _you_ have a valid license.
The reality of copyright is that the scope of authors' rights in works is _huge_. We all regularly violate copyright. (I can't find the original reference, but I remember once reading a draft SCOTUS opinion where a justice wanted to claim that transcribing a poem onto a sheet of paper from a radio broadcast was obviously not a violation of copyright--not fair use, but outside the scope of copyright entirely--but all the other justices quickly corrected him.) However, authors' ability to detect infringement, and their available remedies, are knowingly and intentionally circumscribed. The law often works this way (i.e. rights not being co-extensive with remedies), but it's taken to the extreme in copyright. For one thing, it means that more than most areas of the law, strict legality is quite divorced from your intuition. Also, this can lead to complex conflicts between your personal ethical system and the law.