2 ms·
This article is not that great. I think he means "drivel" instead of "dribble". I find that rants tend to be written in the "heat of the moment", and that cop
by jrockway 16y ago
This article is not that great. I think he means "drivel" instead of "dribble". I find that rants tend to be written in the "heat of the moment", and that copyediting suffers as a result. It would be good for the author to take a deep breath, re-read his writing, and trim it down a bit. It says the same thing over and over, and the "jokes" aren't funny.
It could even be trimmed down to a tweet: "Posterous is offering tools from migrating away from "dead platforms", but these dead platforms seem to have more users than Posterous!"
I also think that the graph is irrelevant. The graph only reflects the number of users with spyware installed. I have a feeling that Posterous appeals to more technical users than Tumblr does, and those users don't browse with tracking enabled. I use Posterous... and use privoxy and have my browser remove Google Analytics code. How many other users are like me? Probably more for Posterous than for Tumblr.
(I also don't post to Posterous from the web interface. I rarely visit my own "blog", although others probably do when I link to it.)
Anyway, choice is always good. Maybe the word "dying" is unnecessary in Posterous' ad copy, but they have a product to sell. Words aside, it's great to be able to get all your old content and bring it somewhere else. The other tools should allow importing from Posterous, and then people can switch back to Tumblr when they find that the grass isn't greener on Posterous' side. But the fact that Tumblr is behind with respect to data migration doesn't mean Posterous is "preposterous" or whatever. It just means they have a clue.
- famfam 16y agoCompete does not work via Spyware alone. They're using a lot of ISP data as well.
- staunch 16y agoCompete is horribly inaccurate. It's not even good for getting trends most of the time. Fortunately, with both these sites we don't even have to guess, they're both directly measured on Quantcast: http://www.quantcast.com/search.jsp?domain=posterous.com http://www.quantcast.com/search.jsp?domain=posterous.com http://www.quantcast.com/search.jsp?domain=tumblr.com http://www.quantcast.com/search.jsp?domain=tumblr.com They're both trending upwards, but Tumblr is going up faster and is far larger than Posterous.
- jrockway 16y agoHow does Quantcast directly measure?
- staunch 16y agoTumblr and Posterous insert Quantcast Javascript into their pages, and it includes their unique Quantcast ID in it. The same way Google Analytics works. From Posterous: <!-- Start Quantcast tag --> <script type="text/javascript"> qoptions={ qacct:"p-16ewveTurfCCM" }; </script> <script type="text/javascript" src="http://edge.quantserve.com/quant.js"></script> <noscript> <a href="http://www.quantcast.com/p-16ewveTurfCCM" target="_blank"> <img src="http://pixel.quantserve.com/pixel/p-16ewveTurfCCM.gif" style="display: none;" border="0" height="1" width="1" alt="Quantcast"/></a> </noscript> <!-- End Quantcast tag -->
- amirmc 16y agoI also don't post to Posterous from the web interface That's an interesting point. I wonder if that has any effect on the compete data. Specifically, if Tumblr users visit the site themselves more often than Posterous users visit theirs.
- studer 16y agoWhere did Posterous claim that Tumblr is dying, btw? Their original blog post says "A lot of you have asked for help moving your old blog, photos or videos to Posterous. You grouched about dying platforms that haven't added new features in ages, sites that have made it too complex to perform the most basic tasks and places that smother your content in ads." You have to read things way too literally to interpret that as "all sites we're going to mention over the next few weeks suffer from all these flaws".