3 ms·
You're throwing out the baby with the bathwater. If mainstream medicine doesn't work for someone, it doesn't mean the solution is voodoo or alternative shit, i
by pas 9y ago
You're throwing out the baby with the bathwater.
If mainstream medicine doesn't work for someone, it doesn't mean the solution is voodoo or alternative shit, it's fixing the healthcare industry, not spending billions on goop.
- maxxxxx 9y agoSeems I didn't express myself precisely enough. I am not advocating jumping on every alternative cure. My comment was about people outright dismissing the guy who wrote that he got his hay fever controlled with supplements. Then they added comments that it would have gone anyway. In short, they dismissed someone's experience without listening any further which I think is wrong. It's also wrong to reflexively dismiss any kind of treatment that's not in medical textbooks. See my comment about meditation. When I started meditating it had the the status of voodoo shit. But now they are coming around.
- Chris2048 9y ago> Then they added comments that it would have gone anyway. Can you quote/link that post? > It's also wrong to reflexively dismiss any kind of treatment that's not in medical textbooks Dismiss as definitely incorrect? Maybe. Defends on what it is. Dismiss as unproven? Perfectly OK.
- maxxxxx 9y agoHere are some quotes from this page: "Simply waiting 4-8 weeks treats the vast majority of common issues." "You know hay fever is an allergy, right? And that you are allergic to specific pollen? These pollen are _seasonal_. It's not suprising that your symptoms are now gone, it's very probable that the allergen is just gone (for the season). The snake-oil has done nothing." "For one, your issues could have healed by themselves, even without it, just through time passing. Since there's a sample of 1 of you, and you did take those drugs, we don't have a control group, and can't know."
- Chris2048 9y agoYeah, I read them. These are alternate explanations your original post hadn't explicitly ruled out - are your claims not open to interrogation? > they dismissed someone's experience I believe I already stated this, but they seem to dismiss your conclusion, not your experience. Your experience is taking the supplement, then soon after experiencing no allergies. This is not contested. These quotes are mostly reasonable since you had at that point omitted the fact of the period of time you had been suffering from hay-fever before trying the supplement. That fact still doesn't rule out these explanations, however, because of survivor bias - which I've also commented on. > The snake-oil has done nothing Even if we accept the supplements as the cause, The proposed mechanism is still not certain. If the mechanism were such that any placebo, nutritional supplement, or change in diet would have had the same effect, I would still consider the product to be snake-oil.