5 ms·
This seems to ultimately come down to an idea that folks have a hard time shaking. It is entirely possible that you cannot recover the original signal using ma
by taeric 9y ago
This seems to ultimately come down to an idea that folks have a hard time shaking. It is entirely possible that you cannot recover the original signal using machine learning. This is, fundamentally, what separates this field from digital sampling.
And this is not unique to machine learning, per se. https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/trump-noncitizen-voters/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/trump-noncitizen-voters... has a great widget that shows that as you get more data, you do not necessarily decrease inherent noise. In fact, it stays very constant. (Granted, this is in large because machine learning has most of its roots in statistics.)
More explicitly, with ML, you are building probabilistic models. This is contrasted to most models folks are used to which are analytic models. That is, you run the calculations for an object moving across the field, and you get something within the measurement bounds that you expected. With a probabilistic model, you get something that is within the bounds of being in line with previous data you have collected.
(None of this is to say this is a bad article. Just a bias to keep in mind as you are reading it. Hopefully, it helps you challenge it.)
- ssivark 9y agoI think the key point is that in the case of sampling, you always assume that your signal has finite bandwidth, so you can claim to avoid aliasing so long as you sample suitably often. Further, the time duration over which one makes measurements puts a cutoff on the frequency resolution. Both of these essentially serve the purpose of implicit model regularization (aka bias). For sufficiently well-behaved signals, the estimator of the strength of various frequency components (i.e. the Fourier transform) is pretty stable as one enlarges the window of measurement, which is post-hoc validation that the signal is well-behaved. This might not be true for very weird signals, and enlarging the window of measurement might significantly change model parameters--meaning that one might need a non-parametric model to get by (enlarging number of parameters with number of measurements) rather than restricting to a finite number of frequency models. Eg: Suppose the first 100 measurements show a nice sinusoid of some frequency, but the next 100 measurements show a pretty much flat signal. Then, you are forced to revise downward the parameter corresponding to the importance of the sinusoid component, and increase the importance of the zero frequency component. The thing is, one never truly knows how the signal is going to behave in the future. Any parametric model is a bias that things won't get too complicated.
- nightski 9y agoThe irreducible error is unrelated to the bias/variance trade-off. It's part of the overall error of course, but the bias/variance error is in addition to that. Unless I am misunderstanding your point.
- taeric 9y agoSorry, I did not mean to be that they were the same. And, to that point, I was greatly projecting based on my beliefs that have grown. The number one thing I keep having to re-stress and learn is that these are probabilistic models. So, if anything, I only meant they were related in that they are both good targets to internalize when working with ML. If there are better targets, I'm definitely interested in learning more.
- xapata 9y agoUltimately, everything is a probabilistic model. It'd be ridiculously impractical to try to incorporate all of one's knowledge into an analytic model. Instead, we generalize as appropriate and encapsulate the rest as a random variable, sometimes called "error". Plus, God plays dice and all that.
- cromd 9y agoIf it helps anyone, the FiveThirtyEight article describes a scenario where people take a survey about immigration status and voting. Most legal citizens will correctly identify themselves, but some will accidentally check the wrong box and say they are an illegal immigrant. If you have a billion citizens and 10 illegal immigrants truly taking the survey, and people check the wrong box 1 in 1000 times, your "percentage of illegal immigrants who vote" statistic will be about the same as for citizens (because almost all reported illegals will be citizens). Collecting more data won't help. It's a very good article, though in the context of deciding how many variables should be in a model of some complex phenomenon, this example is a little tougher to wrap your head around. It's not quite a predictive model, but there were some variables left out. A naive model I suppose is "this data is generated by infallible respondents", whereas a better model would incorporate that error rate. There isn't as much of a question about which pieces of information are relevant, though, like you might encounter when trying to predict future drug use from household income, race, age, number of books read as a child, number of pets, and so on.
- dopamean 9y agoIf you could find a link to the FiveThirtyEight article I'd really appreciate it. Thanks.
- foota 9y agoIt's linked in the grandparent's comment. https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/trump-noncitizen-voters/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/trump-noncitizen-voters...
- corey_moncure 9y agoDoesn't this make the assumption that "illegal immigrants" won't check the wrong box, intentionally or by accident?
- Double_Cast 9y agocitizens labeled illegals: 1,000,000 illegals labeled citizens: 0.01
- mljoe 9y agoFundamentally this is related to the induction fallacy. The doge meme image actually illustrates it pretty well. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Problem_of_induction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Problem_of_induction Another closely related thing is the No Free Lunch Theorem. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_free_lunch_in_search_and_optimization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_free_lunch_in_search_and_op... These are concepts I believe are very important to internalize if you work with machine learning. Fundamentally we are making predictions (ie. guessing) on the nature of entirely unknown information. So there is a certain inherent impossibility to the task in the general sense. It shouldn't always work.