5 ms·
Yes, and the question was where does the tree get it's mass from. I suppose you could look at it in the twisted sense of 'what in the tree contributes so much
by sliverstorm 16y ago
Yes, and the question was where does the tree get it's mass from.
I suppose you could look at it in the twisted sense of 'what in the tree contributes so much to it's mass', but that's a rather tortured use of English.
- Retric 16y agoIf the meant "50% of the mass of some trees is from water" that then he should have said so. Some trees are more than 50% water by mass is a true statement, but it means something else. The author saying something related to the truth, but I think he has a poor understanding of what is going on. Reading that I felt like a teacher who wants to give some created for a student using the correct words while realizing they don't quite get it. As to precision it's more accurate to say 3 +/- 0.5 times 101 +/- 0.5 = 256.25 to 355.25 or 305.75 +/- 49.5 than to just say 300. For an extreme example (1 +/- .1) ^ 1,000 can be any ware from ~2.47e41 to ~1.748e-46. PS: "Dead stars" is a reasonable if incomplete answer to the same question, but context matters so it's not acceptable on a botany or chemistry exam. In the same way that Air + Soil + Water would be missing the point on an astronomy exam.
- ErrantX 16y ago> As to precision it's more accurate to say 3 +/- 0.5 times 101 +/- 0.5 = 256.25 to 355.25 or 305.75 +/- 49.5 than to just say 300. Ah, problem is you've changed the question now. Which is a reasonable thing to do when face with 3 + 101.5 = ?, but not the point the author was making (or, actually, it is the exact point the author is making) :)
- Retric 16y agoEhh, I was trying to show why "significant digests" are a poor approximation of accuracy. His explanation in terms of addition is incomplete. Since "3" only has one significant digit (3.03.0 is a more precise number with 2 significant digits) the answer itself can have no more than one significant figure. 3 +/- .5 + 101.5 +/- .05 = 104.5 +/- 0.55 which has 2 significant digits. Now in his example 3 + 4.7 the three does limit the question to 1 significant digit, but your example has more than that even though your also adding 3 to a number (104.5 +/- 0.55) PS: This is all assuming the accuracy based on the number of digits given you could easily have 3 +/- .0001 and 101.5 +/- 70.
- ErrantX 16y agoPS: This is all assuming the accuracy based on the number of digits given you could easily have 3 +/- .0001 and 101.5 +/- 70. That is the whole point :)